Jimxcomet
@jimxcomet.bsky.social
Occasional dj, former seller of records. Occasionally writes and posts about music and other things. My opinions are my own.
I'm a huge Beatles fan but I can't do the solo stuff. Don't know why. It always seems like somethings missing....probably the other 3 Beatles. Anyway I've just dropped George and Ringo and the shortlist is down to 32.
#5debutalbums7074
#5debutalbums7074
November 26, 2025 at 5:12 PM
I'm a huge Beatles fan but I can't do the solo stuff. Don't know why. It always seems like somethings missing....probably the other 3 Beatles. Anyway I've just dropped George and Ringo and the shortlist is down to 32.
#5debutalbums7074
#5debutalbums7074
Have to be really ruthless already here. I've a shortlist of nearly 50 so The Commodores, Paul McCartney, New York Dolls,Robert Wyatt and Funkadelic all got the boot today.
#5debutalbums7074
#5debutalbums7074
November 25, 2025 at 4:50 PM
Have to be really ruthless already here. I've a shortlist of nearly 50 so The Commodores, Paul McCartney, New York Dolls,Robert Wyatt and Funkadelic all got the boot today.
#5debutalbums7074
#5debutalbums7074
@richards7370.bsky.social
Quick question does the Manassas album qualify or is it regarded as a Stephen Stills album.
#5debutalbums7074
Quick question does the Manassas album qualify or is it regarded as a Stephen Stills album.
#5debutalbums7074
November 24, 2025 at 12:34 PM
@richards7370.bsky.social
Quick question does the Manassas album qualify or is it regarded as a Stephen Stills album.
#5debutalbums7074
Quick question does the Manassas album qualify or is it regarded as a Stephen Stills album.
#5debutalbums7074
Sat out the last one but this will be brilliant.
#5debutalbums7074
#5debutalbums7074
Hi folks, the next poll will commence on Friday 12th December and will feature debut albums released between 1970 to 1974. Please use the hashtag #5debutalbums7074 for recommendations and to give your favourites a plug! You’ll have 3 weeks to decide on your top 5 choices from that era, see you then.
November 23, 2025 at 8:21 PM
Sat out the last one but this will be brilliant.
#5debutalbums7074
#5debutalbums7074
On Hyndford Street is the most Sunday evening song ever.
November 16, 2025 at 6:10 PM
On Hyndford Street is the most Sunday evening song ever.
Nick Cave From Her To Eternity that should read
Hi Richard
My top 5 is
1 Dexys Midnight Runners Searching For The Young Soul Rebels
2 New Order Movement
3 Nick Cave Firstborn Is Dead
4 John Foxx Metamatic
5 Wah Nah=Poo- The Art Of Bluff
#5debutalbums8084
One of the most enjoyable
My top 5 is
1 Dexys Midnight Runners Searching For The Young Soul Rebels
2 New Order Movement
3 Nick Cave Firstborn Is Dead
4 John Foxx Metamatic
5 Wah Nah=Poo- The Art Of Bluff
#5debutalbums8084
One of the most enjoyable
October 24, 2025 at 11:30 PM
Nick Cave From Her To Eternity that should read
Number 1
Searching for the young soul rebels...and he's still searching. A soul album that came in a roundabout way from punk while managing to sound completely unique. Arguably the greatest debut album ever.
#5debutalbums8084
Searching for the young soul rebels...and he's still searching. A soul album that came in a roundabout way from punk while managing to sound completely unique. Arguably the greatest debut album ever.
#5debutalbums8084
October 24, 2025 at 8:42 PM
Number 1
Searching for the young soul rebels...and he's still searching. A soul album that came in a roundabout way from punk while managing to sound completely unique. Arguably the greatest debut album ever.
#5debutalbums8084
Searching for the young soul rebels...and he's still searching. A soul album that came in a roundabout way from punk while managing to sound completely unique. Arguably the greatest debut album ever.
#5debutalbums8084
Number 2
I can remember the anticipation around this coming out. I can remember standing awestruck in my raincoat in the SFX watching them tour it. It was exactly the kind of record that a young Joy Division fan needed them to release.
#5debutalbums8084
I can remember the anticipation around this coming out. I can remember standing awestruck in my raincoat in the SFX watching them tour it. It was exactly the kind of record that a young Joy Division fan needed them to release.
#5debutalbums8084
October 24, 2025 at 8:22 PM
Number 2
I can remember the anticipation around this coming out. I can remember standing awestruck in my raincoat in the SFX watching them tour it. It was exactly the kind of record that a young Joy Division fan needed them to release.
#5debutalbums8084
I can remember the anticipation around this coming out. I can remember standing awestruck in my raincoat in the SFX watching them tour it. It was exactly the kind of record that a young Joy Division fan needed them to release.
#5debutalbums8084
Number 3
It's probably his most inaccessible record but it's certainly one of his best. He interprets raw blues here as only he can. The Bad Seeds are excellent supplying sparse backing for effect while the bass keeps the beat.
#5debutalbums8084
It's probably his most inaccessible record but it's certainly one of his best. He interprets raw blues here as only he can. The Bad Seeds are excellent supplying sparse backing for effect while the bass keeps the beat.
#5debutalbums8084
October 24, 2025 at 7:10 PM
Number 3
It's probably his most inaccessible record but it's certainly one of his best. He interprets raw blues here as only he can. The Bad Seeds are excellent supplying sparse backing for effect while the bass keeps the beat.
#5debutalbums8084
It's probably his most inaccessible record but it's certainly one of his best. He interprets raw blues here as only he can. The Bad Seeds are excellent supplying sparse backing for effect while the bass keeps the beat.
#5debutalbums8084
Number 4
Early 80s late 70s saw a huge resurgence in electronic music. I reckon Low got the ball rolling. This album was a game changer and stood apart. I think he played everything himself on synths he built himself.
#5debutalbums8084
Early 80s late 70s saw a huge resurgence in electronic music. I reckon Low got the ball rolling. This album was a game changer and stood apart. I think he played everything himself on synths he built himself.
#5debutalbums8084
October 24, 2025 at 6:35 PM
Number 4
Early 80s late 70s saw a huge resurgence in electronic music. I reckon Low got the ball rolling. This album was a game changer and stood apart. I think he played everything himself on synths he built himself.
#5debutalbums8084
Early 80s late 70s saw a huge resurgence in electronic music. I reckon Low got the ball rolling. This album was a game changer and stood apart. I think he played everything himself on synths he built himself.
#5debutalbums8084
I'm going to do this early as I'm working later
Number 5
The 3rd band from Liverpool that everyone forgets. A stunning underrated debut with a great production and a really atmospheric vibe to it. Didn't expect this to make my 5 to be honest.
#5debutalbums8084
Number 5
The 3rd band from Liverpool that everyone forgets. A stunning underrated debut with a great production and a really atmospheric vibe to it. Didn't expect this to make my 5 to be honest.
#5debutalbums8084
October 24, 2025 at 6:06 PM
I'm going to do this early as I'm working later
Number 5
The 3rd band from Liverpool that everyone forgets. A stunning underrated debut with a great production and a really atmospheric vibe to it. Didn't expect this to make my 5 to be honest.
#5debutalbums8084
Number 5
The 3rd band from Liverpool that everyone forgets. A stunning underrated debut with a great production and a really atmospheric vibe to it. Didn't expect this to make my 5 to be honest.
#5debutalbums8084
Number 6
Took a chance on this years ago because I wanted to get into a band that nobody else had heard of and they seemed a good bet. They were. First 3 albums are brilliant and I still listen to them. Hard to leave this one out.
#5debutalbums8084
Took a chance on this years ago because I wanted to get into a band that nobody else had heard of and they seemed a good bet. They were. First 3 albums are brilliant and I still listen to them. Hard to leave this one out.
#5debutalbums8084
October 23, 2025 at 10:59 PM
Number 6
Took a chance on this years ago because I wanted to get into a band that nobody else had heard of and they seemed a good bet. They were. First 3 albums are brilliant and I still listen to them. Hard to leave this one out.
#5debutalbums8084
Took a chance on this years ago because I wanted to get into a band that nobody else had heard of and they seemed a good bet. They were. First 3 albums are brilliant and I still listen to them. Hard to leave this one out.
#5debutalbums8084
Number 7
First time I heard Sister Europe on the radio I thought it was a Bowie track that I'd somehow missed out on. I always felt the Psychedelic Furs channelled him brilliantly.
I prefer the 2nd album but this is a great debut.
#5debutalbums8084
First time I heard Sister Europe on the radio I thought it was a Bowie track that I'd somehow missed out on. I always felt the Psychedelic Furs channelled him brilliantly.
I prefer the 2nd album but this is a great debut.
#5debutalbums8084
October 23, 2025 at 10:19 PM
Number 7
First time I heard Sister Europe on the radio I thought it was a Bowie track that I'd somehow missed out on. I always felt the Psychedelic Furs channelled him brilliantly.
I prefer the 2nd album but this is a great debut.
#5debutalbums8084
First time I heard Sister Europe on the radio I thought it was a Bowie track that I'd somehow missed out on. I always felt the Psychedelic Furs channelled him brilliantly.
I prefer the 2nd album but this is a great debut.
#5debutalbums8084
Number 8
This was originally meant to be a project by the BEF formed after a split in the Human League but a brilliant debut album followed by the single Temptation put paid to that. Album still sounds brilliant. Love the contrasting sides.
#5debutalbums8084
This was originally meant to be a project by the BEF formed after a split in the Human League but a brilliant debut album followed by the single Temptation put paid to that. Album still sounds brilliant. Love the contrasting sides.
#5debutalbums8084
October 23, 2025 at 9:41 PM
Number 8
This was originally meant to be a project by the BEF formed after a split in the Human League but a brilliant debut album followed by the single Temptation put paid to that. Album still sounds brilliant. Love the contrasting sides.
#5debutalbums8084
This was originally meant to be a project by the BEF formed after a split in the Human League but a brilliant debut album followed by the single Temptation put paid to that. Album still sounds brilliant. Love the contrasting sides.
#5debutalbums8084
Number 9
This came along just at the right time when the post punk thing started to get stale and formulaic. Something new was needed and they provided. I made the entire journey with them up to the final album and they never disappointed.
#5debutalbums8084
This came along just at the right time when the post punk thing started to get stale and formulaic. Something new was needed and they provided. I made the entire journey with them up to the final album and they never disappointed.
#5debutalbums8084
October 23, 2025 at 8:52 PM
Number 9
This came along just at the right time when the post punk thing started to get stale and formulaic. Something new was needed and they provided. I made the entire journey with them up to the final album and they never disappointed.
#5debutalbums8084
This came along just at the right time when the post punk thing started to get stale and formulaic. Something new was needed and they provided. I made the entire journey with them up to the final album and they never disappointed.
#5debutalbums8084
Time to cut from 10 down to the final 5.
Number 10
The ultimate make music in your bedroom independent album. It still sounds edgy today and it hasn't lost any of it's charm. Seem to remember about 5 people in my class had this and it still retains a cult status.
#5debutalbums8084
Number 10
The ultimate make music in your bedroom independent album. It still sounds edgy today and it hasn't lost any of it's charm. Seem to remember about 5 people in my class had this and it still retains a cult status.
#5debutalbums8084
October 23, 2025 at 7:56 PM
Time to cut from 10 down to the final 5.
Number 10
The ultimate make music in your bedroom independent album. It still sounds edgy today and it hasn't lost any of it's charm. Seem to remember about 5 people in my class had this and it still retains a cult status.
#5debutalbums8084
Number 10
The ultimate make music in your bedroom independent album. It still sounds edgy today and it hasn't lost any of it's charm. Seem to remember about 5 people in my class had this and it still retains a cult status.
#5debutalbums8084
Soft Cell weren't just a pop group. They had a lot more depth and darkness than their contemporaries. Great lyrics, great frontman heavily influenced by Northern Soul and the great David Ball in the engine room. Great debut but it won't go any further.
#5debutalbums8084
#5debutalbums8084
October 22, 2025 at 9:23 PM
Soft Cell weren't just a pop group. They had a lot more depth and darkness than their contemporaries. Great lyrics, great frontman heavily influenced by Northern Soul and the great David Ball in the engine room. Great debut but it won't go any further.
#5debutalbums8084
#5debutalbums8084
My favourite version of Microdisney is when they were a duo just before they left Cork, my favourite song is Pink Skinned Man, so the debut for me was very much a London record and I was on the fence for a while.
Off the fence now but it won't make my final 10.
#5debutalbums8084
Off the fence now but it won't make my final 10.
#5debutalbums8084
October 22, 2025 at 7:53 PM
My favourite version of Microdisney is when they were a duo just before they left Cork, my favourite song is Pink Skinned Man, so the debut for me was very much a London record and I was on the fence for a while.
Off the fence now but it won't make my final 10.
#5debutalbums8084
Off the fence now but it won't make my final 10.
#5debutalbums8084
Have to cut this list down from 15 to 10 and it's proving really difficult because they're all potentially top 5.
I'll reluctantly start with these 3.
#5debutalbums8084
I'll reluctantly start with these 3.
#5debutalbums8084
October 22, 2025 at 5:33 PM
Have to cut this list down from 15 to 10 and it's proving really difficult because they're all potentially top 5.
I'll reluctantly start with these 3.
#5debutalbums8084
I'll reluctantly start with these 3.
#5debutalbums8084
Late 70s early 80s there was a great post punk scene here. Lot of the bands largely forgotten. This was a great debut. Treasure On The Wasteland has one of the greatest intros ever. I'd love to put this in my final 5 but it won't fit.
#5debutalbums8084
#5debutalbums8084
October 21, 2025 at 9:31 PM
Late 70s early 80s there was a great post punk scene here. Lot of the bands largely forgotten. This was a great debut. Treasure On The Wasteland has one of the greatest intros ever. I'd love to put this in my final 5 but it won't fit.
#5debutalbums8084
#5debutalbums8084
Time to cut these down from 20 to 15 so I'm reluctantly letting these 4 go.
#5debutalbums8084
#5debutalbums8084
October 21, 2025 at 7:07 PM
Time to cut these down from 20 to 15 so I'm reluctantly letting these 4 go.
#5debutalbums8084
#5debutalbums8084
Originally formed as a musical vehicle for Steve Strange they were like a post punk Wilburys featuring members of Ultravox,Magazine and The Skids. The album was really good and it's stood the test of time.
However it won't go further than my final 25.
#5debutalbums8084
However it won't go further than my final 25.
#5debutalbums8084
October 20, 2025 at 3:20 PM
Originally formed as a musical vehicle for Steve Strange they were like a post punk Wilburys featuring members of Ultravox,Magazine and The Skids. The album was really good and it's stood the test of time.
However it won't go further than my final 25.
#5debutalbums8084
However it won't go further than my final 25.
#5debutalbums8084
This is one of the most enjoyable of the #albums series and it'll be really hard to cut them down. I'll start with these 4 cutting my shortlist from 25 to 20.
#5debutalbums8084
#5debutalbums8084
October 20, 2025 at 10:13 AM
This is one of the most enjoyable of the #albums series and it'll be really hard to cut them down. I'll start with these 4 cutting my shortlist from 25 to 20.
#5debutalbums8084
#5debutalbums8084
It's a good debut but the genius didn't really kick in until Zen Arcade even though there's hints on this record.
It won't make my final 25.
#5debutalbums8084
It won't make my final 25.
#5debutalbums8084
October 12, 2025 at 8:29 AM
It's a good debut but the genius didn't really kick in until Zen Arcade even though there's hints on this record.
It won't make my final 25.
#5debutalbums8084
It won't make my final 25.
#5debutalbums8084