Johnsays
@johnsays.bsky.social
370 followers 270 following 1.4K posts
Posts Media Videos Starter Packs
I'll go further. It couldn't survive even if we all wanted it to - which increasingly we don't.
Haha. It's cute how you hang on so tenaciously to your favourite fairy story. The monarchy will end.
I don't advocate for a directly elected president. I think the role should be a boring one.
If the queen could manage it for 70 years a president could cope for 4.
I'm not claiming to have a panacea. I'm arguing that the problems that have been asserted are not insurmountable.
Disagree. There is never a bad time to discuss the monarchy. And when one of the Royal family is in the middle of a sex abuse scandal, it is a brilliant time to discuss the monarchy.
OK you go on thinking it's insurmountable. But please stop trying to persuade me. I'm not convinced by your pessimism.
It's no less plausible than other changes which don't number among most people's priorities. You managed to have a referendum on marriage equality, despite it affecting only a small minority.
Not necessarily. It could be an accomplished individual drawn from academia, the arts, business, or sport.
Say the rest! Fucking cowards.
Because it was designed to fail.
Yeah, but that referendum was a travesty. It's amazing you haven't had another one.
I don't think it needs to be directly elected. It should be a boring position. It's the political leadership that should be inspiring people to vote for them. A president shouldn't be partisan or chasing votes.
Why so you think these are such insurmountable problems? Yes, obviously if you change the method of appointment you need to agree a new method of appointment. Why should that be where we all give up?
You replicate the functions of the existing head of state with a new method of appointment. It isn't complicated.
Yeah but at least you can replace them next time.
They've got no choice. They are running out of people. Most of the royals are in their 60s at least.
Yep, the best way to be a wealthy land owner in 2025 is to be descended from a mate of William the Conqueror. Not even a joke.
There's that evergreen excuse for doing nothing again.
Just be like Germany or Italy where no one knows or cares.
That is such a stupid reply. At best the only tourism revenue that can tenuously be attributed to the royals comes from people visiting the palaces. The Versailles example shows that royal palaces function perfectly well as tourist attractions without royal families.