Author | Lightnews

All Joe Jeromes Are Belong to Us @joejerome.bsky.social · 18d

Hard to see how folks can keep saying AI isn’t a part of the Google Search antitrust case when Google is selling search grounding as an AI service:

Gemini API and Google AI Studio now offer Grounding with Google Search- Google Developers Blog

Grounding with Google Search for the Gemini API and Google AI Studio enhances the accuracy and freshness of Gemini's responses by leveraging Google Search data.

developers.googleblog.com

All Joe Jeromes Are Belong to Us @joejerome.bsky.social · 18d

Of course, Google will fight this tooth and nail, and probably have AI draft 25% of their talking points about data access remedies. Full article is here:

Google Antitrust Remedies: Promoting Competition Without Punishing Users

Considering how to increase competition in the search space without damaging end users is a trickier question than it seems at first. Many of the suggestions that people have tossed out have tended…

www.techdirt.com

All Joe Jeromes Are Belong to Us @joejerome.bsky.social · 18d

"So the proposals from the DOJ that match DDG’s suggestion of API access are much more interesting (and probably better) overall… It creates a scenario for increased competition without a corresponding harm to users or to other competitors.”

Couldn’t put it better myself!

1

All Joe Jeromes Are Belong to Us @joejerome.bsky.social · 18d

Taking a World Series programming break to notice that @techdirt has a piece out on what to do about Google’s search monopoly: "The most reasonable suggestion seemed to be @DuckDuckGo main suggestion."

1

All Joe Jeromes Are Belong to Us @joejerome.bsky.social · 18d

Meta AI’s “open access” includes usage restrictions that prohibit the use of Meta’s model to train rival LLMs and "the need to acquire a license once a business surpasses 700 million users,” note @danielahanley and @maxvonthun

Open Markets Institute & Mozilla Release New Report on Preventing Monopoly Control Over AI and Promoting Open Innovation & the Public Good — Open Markets Institute

The Open Markets Institute and Mozilla published a comprehensive report titled "Stop Big Tech from Becoming Big AI: A Roadmap for Using Competition Policy to Keep Artificial Intelligence Open for All.”

www.openmarketsinstitute.org

All Joe Jeromes Are Belong to Us @joejerome.bsky.social · 18d

So @DuckDuckGo wants signal to startups, potential partners, and the larger tech community that our door is open to anyone who wants to work with us on a more private Internet:

DuckDuckGo will be making more early-stage investments in privacy-focused startups | TechCrunch

DuckDuckGo is pledging to invest in privacy-focused startups -- both in a venture capital capacity, and through acquisitions.

techcrunch.com

All Joe Jeromes Are Belong to Us @joejerome.bsky.social · 18d

Really enjoying @chapell68’s writings — and history lesson on the DNT war:

The Monopoly Report

In-depth coverage of advertising privacy, policy and antitrust from Marketecture. Written by Alan Chapell and Ari Paparo.

monopoly.marketecture.tv

All Joe Jeromes Are Belong to Us @joejerome.bsky.social · 18d

I’m embarrassed to tweet that I did not guess correctly.

Guess who’s suing the FTC to stop ‘click to cancel’

Who would have guessed?

www.theverge.com

All Joe Jeromes Are Belong to Us @joejerome.bsky.social · 18d

Meta @OversightBoard recommends changing community guidelines to stop the sharing of private residential information when it is considered 'publicly available’ in 2021.

Three years later:

Meta bans jet-tracking accounts that post updates on Trump, Musk and Zuckerberg

Meta said the actions were taken because of "the risk of physical harm to individuals."

www.nbcnews.com

All Joe Jeromes Are Belong to Us @joejerome.bsky.social · 18d

“Not covering the extraordinary story of Concord reveals a deep failure in the mainstream press, and one born of a silly prejudice against a medium that towers over the films and television that such outlets are willing to understand.”

A Video Game Flopped Harder Than Anything At The Box Office This Year, And The Mainstream Press Barely Noticed - Kotaku

Sony's Concord might be the biggest entertainment failure of all time, so why wasn't it news?

kotaku.com

All Joe Jeromes Are Belong to Us @joejerome.bsky.social · 18d

Truly fail to understand how this helps users. Do get that this is another way for Meta to try to boost engagement.

Threads will start showing others when you're online by default | TechCrunch

Threads is rolling out a new "activity status" feature that will let you see when someone on the social network is online.

techcrunch.com

All Joe Jeromes Are Belong to Us @joejerome.bsky.social · 18d

Google broke the law. Now argues fixing that will destroy capitalism.

All Joe Jeromes Are Belong to Us @joejerome.bsky.social · 18d

I look forward to seeing what Google believes is a reasonable restriction on its business. I guess we’ll all find out in December! G’night!

All Joe Jeromes Are Belong to Us @joejerome.bsky.social · 18d

Considering the other adtech competition case, I think you take Google’s claims about online advertising with a grain of salt.

1

All Joe Jeromes Are Belong to Us @joejerome.bsky.social · 18d

Again, parallels to the breakup of the phone company. This is effectively platform hostage taking, and a divorce between OS/browser and search certainly doesn’t break the products.

1

All Joe Jeromes Are Belong to Us @joejerome.bsky.social · 18d

“America’s technological leadership” depends on protecting a monopolist’s ability to dominate in AI. It’s a compelling rhetorical argument, but it’s functionally little different from previous arguments that breaking up the phone company would hurt national security.

1

All Joe Jeromes Are Belong to Us @joejerome.bsky.social · 18d

A few quick thoughts:
(1) Sharing click and query data is already the law of the land in the EU, which has stronger privacy rules than the U.S. anyway.
(2) Google’s highlighted argument is a hedge. DuckDuckGo argues the opposite, that this increases incentives to differentiate.

1

All Joe Jeromes Are Belong to Us @joejerome.bsky.social · 18d

And @googlepubpolicy is out with a response to the DOJ’s remedies framework (and is engaging in a bit a publishing time travel):

1

All Joe Jeromes Are Belong to Us @joejerome.bsky.social · 18d

Anybody else just refreshing, waiting for the DOJ’s remedy framework for Google’s anticompetitive search practices?

All Joe Jeromes Are Belong to Us @joejerome.bsky.social · 18d

“Privacy is valuable not because it empowers us to exercise control over our information, but because it protects against the creation of such information in the first place.”

What Is Privacy For?

We often want to keep some information to ourselves. But information itself may be the problem.

www.newyorker.com

All Joe Jeromes Are Belong to Us @joejerome.bsky.social · 18d

Oh dear. First Amendment Twitter is gonna be triggered.

All Joe Jeromes Are Belong to Us @joejerome.bsky.social · 18d

AI and copyright is fraught, but I take some issue with statements like this from a company built on UGC.

Mark Zuckerberg: creators and publishers ‘overestimate the value’ of their work for training AI

Meta could strike deals for “really important” work.

www.theverge.com

All Joe Jeromes Are Belong to Us @joejerome.bsky.social · 18d

Meta just announced the Hyperscape app at #MetaConnect2024, which allows people to explore detailed maps of spaces. Just your gentle reminder that detailed spatial mapping raises some interesting privacy, property and safety considerations:

All Joe Jeromes Are Belong to Us @joejerome.bsky.social · 18d

Earlier this year, I joined my old boss @MichelleDeMooy to talk about the Youths and tech policy for @McCourtSchool’s Asterisk podcast:

Data Privacy, TikTok & the Kitchen Sink of Tech Policy: A Conversation with Program Director Michelle DeMooy and Visiting Fellow Joseph Jerome

Podcast Episode · The Asterisk: Todays Tech Policy Upload · 09/03/2024 · 31m

podcasts.apple.com

All Joe Jeromes Are Belong to Us @joejerome.bsky.social · 18d

We can open up Google without opening up user data. Licensing Google’s search results does not involve accessing any user data. This remedy will not invade users' privacy! 5/5