Lightnews — Scholar-powered news

Joseph Finlay @josephfinlay.bsky.social · 1d

As with all ideologies, if people and institutions claim to uphold it then it exists

Joseph Finlay @josephfinlay.bsky.social · 2d

Expressing worry is not the same as blaming. And we underestimate the diaspora’s power. Clear statements from major orgs that any return to war/failure to fully withdraw is unacceptable would have an impact on Israel. And if not it would encourage our own gvts to be tougher on Israel eg. sanctions.

1

Joseph Finlay @josephfinlay.bsky.social · 2d

I fear that diaspora Jewish communal statements welcoming the deal that frame it purely in terms of bringing home the hostages make it more likely that the Israeli government will resume the war (or at least never fully withdraw from Gaza) once the hostages are freed.

1 2 4

Joseph Finlay @josephfinlay.bsky.social · 2d

How about the Jewish Chronicle?

It is hard to describe an organisation which has done more to damage interfaith cohesion between Jews and Muslims in this country than 5 Pillars

5

Reposted by Joseph Finlay

Sathnam Sanghera @sathnam.bsky.social · 2d

In @thetimes.com letters page today

6 140 600

Joseph Finlay @josephfinlay.bsky.social · 2d

The deal is a huge relief. But it could have been made 2 years ago on the same terms. Netanyahu promised that he would defeat and destroy Hamas. Instead he signed a deal with them. So many killed for the impossible promise of total
victory and ‘permanent security’.

1 5

Joseph Finlay @josephfinlay.bsky.social · 3d

One more share for this - on why the British state bears some responsibility for the Manchester attack and how racialised minorities should provide security for one another josephfinlay.com/weareeachoth...

We Are Each Other’s Security - Joseph Finlay

British Jews should reject the British state’s philosemitic embrace in the wake of the terrible Manchester synagogue attack.

josephfinlay.com

4

Joseph Finlay @josephfinlay.bsky.social · 3d

Rejecting the British state’s philosemitic embrace in the wake of the Manchester attack

josephfinlay.com/weareeachoth...

We Are Each Other’s Security - Joseph Finlay

British Jews should reject the British state’s philosemitic embrace in the wake of the terrible Manchester synagogue attack.

josephfinlay.com

2 3

Joseph Finlay @josephfinlay.bsky.social · 3d

I wrote a piece about the Manchester attack, on why the British state bears a degree of responsibility and how Jews and Muslim communities would be safer if they provided security for each other.

josephfinlay.com/weareeachoth...

We Are Each Other’s Security - Joseph Finlay

British Jews should reject the British state’s philosemitic embrace in the wake of the terrible Manchester synagogue attack.

josephfinlay.com

1 4

Joseph Finlay @josephfinlay.bsky.social · 4d

There should be no doubt that Robert Jenrick is a racist. His disgraceful Birmingham comments would have seen him sacked by previous Tory leaders. It wasn't much noticed but this video from May is full of Judeo-Bolshevik tropes about Attorney General Ricard Hermer. www.youtube.com/watch?v=tE0P...

Jenrick's EXPLOSIVE takedown of Starmer's Attorney General for "defending Britain's enemies"

YouTube video by Daily Express

www.youtube.com

3

Joseph Finlay @josephfinlay.bsky.social · 5d

But they were attempting to reach Palestine’s waters. A state which you have just recognised.

Adam Bienkov @adambienkov.bsky.social · 5d

Keir Starmer’s spokesman asked about Israel detaining British citizens who were on the Gaza aid flotilla, while in international waters, replies that it is a “matter for the Israeli Government”

1 4

Joseph Finlay @josephfinlay.bsky.social · 6d

As Zionism is to Judaism one might say

Jewish News @jewishnews.bsky.social · 6d

The Jewish Leadership Council said Islamism “is not Islam: it is a political ideology that twists religious belief into a mandate for violence".

Government urged to ‘name and shame’ Islamist motives behind Manchester attack

The Jewish Leadership Council said Islamism “is not Islam: it is a political ideology that twists religious belief into a mandate for violence".

www.jewishnews.co.uk

2 10

Joseph Finlay @josephfinlay.bsky.social · 7d

Absolute unhinged nonsense from @boardofdeputies.bsky.social

STATEMENT: Board of Deputies calls for more than 400 protest terror arrests to also be investigated for stirring up racial hatred

The Board of Deputies utterly condemns the morally grotesque protests that took place today and over recent days.

After the most deadly attack on British Jews since the York Massacre of 1190, we called for the protests to be stopped out of respect to the dead. Politicians and police echoed our community’s call, stressing the burden of policing this rally while providing enhanced protection to more than 300 synagogues across our traumatised community.

The crass insensitivity shown by the protesters, more than 400 of whom were arrested for supporting a proscribed terrorist organisation, is an offence to public decency.

That they would go ahead despite our pleas shows such reckless disregard for public safety and our community’s wellbeing that we consider the underlying motivation to be not just their support for terror, but that they are antisemitic acts, designed to stir up racial hatred. As such we are calling today for those arrested to also be investigated and prosecuted for stirring up racial hatred.

We are demanding that the Government look again at the legislation and powers available to police to stop this continued assault on community relations, city centres, and stretched police resources. What is happening on our streets is just not acceptable. Freedom to protest must come alongside a sense of decency and civil responsibility that seems to completely evade these hateful marchers.

5 14 54

Joseph Finlay @josephfinlay.bsky.social · 7d

The more I think about it the clearer it is: if you say that anti-genocide protests should be called off because of British Jewish sensibilities you are saying that British Jews support genocide. It’s disgraceful and it’s the kind of conflationist discourse that laid the ground for this attack.

1 16

Joseph Finlay @josephfinlay.bsky.social · 8d

This is not it Simon

Joseph Finlay @josephfinlay.bsky.social · 8d

Since it's emerged that one of the victims in Manchester died from a police bullet it's clear that the existence of armed police in Britain is part of this story.

1 8

Joseph Finlay @josephfinlay.bsky.social · 9d

British Jews are tired. Quite literally tired after 25 hours of fasting and intensive prayers. So please don’t expect quick and thoughtful takes on the Manchester synagogue attack from us. Give us a few days.

2 8

Joseph Finlay @josephfinlay.bsky.social · 10d

If an international protectorate is such a great idea for Gaza why not apply it to the whole land between the river and the sea? Call it the Mandate 2.0.

1

Joseph Finlay @josephfinlay.bsky.social · 10d

Longstanding rule of British politics: being racist is normal and understandable, calling someone else a racist is completely unacceptable.

4 11

Joseph Finlay @josephfinlay.bsky.social · 11d

New liturgy for Yom Kippur about Gaza forward.com/opinion/7726...

'For the sins we have committed': Reimagining Yom Kippur liturgy in a post-Oct. 7 world

Hovering over this 5786 holiday season is a sense of moral and spiritual crisis that calls out for liturgical innovation.

forward.com

Joseph Finlay @josephfinlay.bsky.social · 11d

Is there a Labour Party accent? You don’t get anywhere in the party without that nasal twang

Joseph Finlay @josephfinlay.bsky.social · 11d

I don’t think Hamas has much to gain from agreeing to this plan. There seems to be no full IDF withdrawal from Gaza promised which is a major red line. And Gaza is already destroyed. On the other hand, Israel needs a deal imminently; it is facing major international isolation and sanctions.

1 3

Joseph Finlay @josephfinlay.bsky.social · 11d

Seems there were some 11th hour changes to the Trump plan to make it more palatable to Israel, which will make it harder for Hamas to agree to it www.timesofisrael.com/netanyahu-se...

Netanyahu secures key edits to Trump plan to slow and limit Israel’s withdrawal from Gaza

US proposal for ending war says IDF will only pull back when specific benchmarks met and buffer zone to be established, after earlier version was more vague on Israel's red lines

www.timesofisrael.com

Joseph Finlay @josephfinlay.bsky.social · 12d

The most notable thing about this plan is that clearly no Palestinians were consulted. It continues the longstanding tendency to assume the Palestinian people don’t exist, that they are generic ‘Arabs’ who should be happy to live anywhere and accept whatever crumbs the west throws them.

1 3 11

Joseph Finlay @josephfinlay.bsky.social · 12d

Given that the plan is an incoherent mess with diverse and even contradictory parts the smart move is for each side to accept it and simply emphasise the parts that they like and play down the rest. It’s unlikely to be implemented in full anyway.

3