Kapindar Sharma
banner
kapindarsharma.bsky.social
Kapindar Sharma
@kapindarsharma.bsky.social
5 followers 0 following 300 posts
Member of FPSB | Member of AAFM | Blogger | Writer | Entrepreneur | Investor
Posts Media Videos Starter Packs
At the end of the day, this isn’t just about shares — it’s about #legacy, control and survival. And when giants decide to chart their next move, patience and structure often outlast theatrics.

Until the swap settles…
If the deal goes through, it signals a new phase for one of India’s oldest #business relationships.
In short, a share-swap exit could be the most elegant way for SP to monetise its historic stake — without triggering taxes, #governance issues, or activist pressures. And for TATA Sons, this could be the end of a nearly century-long chapter.
For SP, this isn’t just about #money — it’s about choosing a strategic exit without disturbing TATA’s broader control ecosystem. And for the TATAs, it’s a clean solution that keeps the company private, avoids a share-sale frenzy and limits valuation disputes.
Challenges Remain: regulatory approvals, valuation consensus, lender consents due to SP’s pledged holding, and possible scrutiny by #NCLT or Securities and Exchange Board of India. Talks are at a preliminary stage and may still change shape.
The TATAs also view this as a way to defuse the ongoing SP debate without breaking TATA Sons’ control structure. Minor stake dilution across listed TATA entities is unlikely to disrupt operations while providing #liquidity to SP.
TATA Sons doesn’t want new external investors, nor is it keen to list. A direct buyout could trigger large capital gains tax and increase its financial leverage. Hence, equity #swap appears to be the most viable middle path.
This is not SP’s first attempt to exit via #equity swap — a similar offer was rejected in 2020 amid valuation disputes during a public fallout with chairman Ratan Tata. But since then, the landscape has changed and talks have resurfaced.
The move could help SP manage its heavy #debt — estimated at ₹60,000 Cr., much of it linked to engineering and construction projects — while allowing the TATAs to retain control of privately held TATA Sons. SP would be free to sell its holdings gradually in the public market.
The Idea: Shapoorji Pallonji (SP) would either fully or partially surrender its stake in TATA Sons, India’s most influential private holding company, in exchange for liquid, listed shares. This would give SP a way to raise cash without taking the company #public.
TATA–SP Breakup 2.0: Can a Share Swap Keep the Peace This Time?

#TATA Group & the Shapoorji Pallonji Groups are exploring a share swap solution to restructure their partnership — more than 18% equity held by SP might be exchanged for a basket of shares in listed TATA Companies.
The Idea: Shapoorji Pallonji (SP) would either fully or partially surrender its stake in TATA Sons, India’s most influential private holding company, in exchange for liquid, listed shares. This would give SP a way to raise cash without taking the company #public.
At the end of the day, SGBs remain one of the safest gold #investments — combining price upside, interest income, and tax efficiency. But when SGBs trade significantly ahead of spot gold, patience usually pays off more than overpaying.

Until the premium fades… 🌟
#Premature redemption is possible after five years, but returns may not justify buying at a premium. Instead, waiting for premium compression or investing through gold ETFs could be smarter short-term alternatives.
Another Factor - #Liquidity. Many secondary SGB series are thinly traded, meaning you might struggle to sell before maturity without accepting a discount. Long-term holding is often safer unless volumes improve.
So, should you buy SGBs in the secondary market now? Most experts advise keeping an eye on price gaps — buying only when SGBs #trade close to or below spot gold prices reduces the risk of capital loss.
SGBs have also delivered huge #returns in the past — some tranches have generated 190%–200% over several years. However, premiums mean that returns could look less attractive if gold prices stabilise or fall.
Retail investors are piling in, attracted by the 2.5% annual interest and tax-free #capital gains if held till maturity. But the catch is clear: paying a premium means you need higher future gold prices just to break even.
With no new issues since early 2024, market traders are snapping up listed #SGBs — often paying ₹11,500 per gram, while spot gold trades near ₹11,000. The scarcity makes secondary SGBs more expensive, but it also eats into potential returns.
Why SGB Demand Is Skyrocketing?

#Gold is touching all-time highs this festive season & investor interest in sovereign gold bonds is at a record. However, as demand surges and prices hit new peaks, SGBs are trading at large premiums on exchanges.
How soon that happens will decide when investors jump back in.

Until silver flows stabilize…
At the end of the day, the pause on silver ETF inflows isn’t a sign of panic — it’s a sign of prudence. When premiums spike and physical supply dries up, slowing new #money protects everyone. The market recalibrates only when the fundamentals stabilize.
Instead a staggered investment approach — investing gradually through SIPs — is often better than a lumpsum buy during this premium phase. Watching premiums and #NAV alignment will be key before reentering.
Growing #global demand & steady deficits hint at continued supply stress. Experts recommend investors avoid buying into silver ETFs at current elevated levels.
Looking longer term, silver’s industrial demand tailwinds remain strong. Its rising use in EV Batteries, Solar Panels, #5G Infrastructure, & Electronics is reshaping it as a key industrial metal — not just a safe-haven asset.