Author | Lightnews

Learning Accelerators @learningaccelerators.com · Dec 19

10/10

Here is the preprint version of the study report with citation:

Gregory Kestin*, Kelly Miller*, Anna Klales et al. AI Tutoring Outperforms Active Learning, 14 May 2024, PREPRINT (Version 1) available at Research Square:

AI Tutoring Outperforms Active Learning

Advances in generative artificial intelligence (GAI) show great potential for improving education. Yet little is known about how this new technology should be used and how effective it can be. Here we...

www.researchsquare.com

1

Learning Accelerators @learningaccelerators.com · Dec 19

9/10
Inspired by these results, the Derek Bok Center for Teaching and Learning is collaborating with Harvard University Information Technology to pilot similar AI chatbots in other courses. They are also developing resources to enable any instructor to integrate tutor bots into their programmes.

1

Learning Accelerators @learningaccelerators.com · Dec 19

8/10

3. Greater Efficiency: AI sessions were shorter (median 49 minutes vs. 60 minutes) while achieving better outcomes, with 70% finishing within 60 minutes.

1

Learning Accelerators @learningaccelerators.com · Dec 19

7/10

2. Higher Engagement and Motivation: AI users reported greater engagement (4.1/5 vs. 3.6/5) and motivation (3.4/5 vs. 3.1/5).

1

Learning Accelerators @learningaccelerators.com · Dec 19

6/10

Key study findings include:

1. Enhanced Learning Gains:
Students using the AI tutor achieved more than double the learning gains of the classroom group, with highly significant statistical results (z = -5.6, p < 10⁻⁸).

1 1

Learning Accelerators @learningaccelerators.com · Dec 19

5/10
Controls aimed to ensure fairness, including matched demographics, unbiased test designs, and separate instructors.

Dr Philippa Hardman has completed this detailed review of the study exploring the study's methodology, for those seeking independent insights.

AI Tutors Double Rates of Learning in Less Learning Time

Inside Harvard's new groundbreaking study

drphilippahardman.substack.com

1

Learning Accelerators @learningaccelerators.com · Dec 19

4/10
The AI group used “PS2 Pal,” powered by GPT-4, which provided structured, self-paced guidance with pre-recorded videos and interactive support.

The classroom group attended 75-minute in-person sessions with peer discussions and instructor guidance.

1 1

Learning Accelerators @learningaccelerators.com · Dec 19

3/10
The study trailed in the Harvard Gazette in September compared AI tutoring to active classroom learning using a crossover design. Students studied two topics, surface tension and fluid flow, in both settings.

1

Learning Accelerators @learningaccelerators.com · Dec 19

2/10
The study was led by lecturer Gregory Kestin and senior lecturer Kelly Miller who analysed the learning outcomes of 194 students enrolled in autumn 2023 in Kestin’s Physical Sciences 2 course, which is physics for life sciences majors.

This Forbes article explains the circumstances.

Students Learned Twice As Much With AI Tutor Than Typical Lectures

Harvard University researchers found AI tutored students learned more in less time but stress that AI tutors are a resource, not a replacement for teachers.

www.forbes.com

1

Learning Accelerators @learningaccelerators.com · Dec 19

A recent Harvard University study, currently under peer review, finds providing students with an AI tutor tailored on pedagogical principles doubled engagement and learning gains in less time than traditional face-to-face sessions.

Thread 1/10

#physics #pedagogy #ai #genai #EduSky #universities

Professor tailored AI tutor to physics course. Engagement doubled. — Harvard Gazette

Preliminary findings inspire other large Harvard classes to test approach this fall

news.harvard.edu

1 2

Learning Accelerators @learningaccelerators.com · Dec 12

10/10
Follow the link to the full research report: “Associations of accelerometer-measured sedentary behavior and physical activity with sleep in older adults" below.

Associations of accelerometer-measured sedentary behavior and physical activity with sleep in older adults

Few studies have examined the non-linear relationships of objectively-measured sedentary behavior and physical activity with insomnia symptoms in olde…

www.sciencedirect.com

Learning Accelerators @learningaccelerators.com · Dec 12

9/10
Getting more sleep, particularly deep sleep, seems to add to this memory improvement.

"Moderate or vigorous activity means anything that gets your heart rate up -- this could be brisk walking, dancing or walking up a few flights of stairs. It doesn't have to be structured exercise”

1

Learning Accelerators @learningaccelerators.com · Dec 12

8/10
Lead author Dr Mikaela Bloomberg (said: "Our findings suggest that the short-term memory benefits of physical activity may last longer than previously thought, possibly to the next day instead of just the few hours after exercise.”

1

Learning Accelerators @learningaccelerators.com · Dec 12

7/10
They also accounted for participants' average levels of activity and sleep quality across the eight days they were tracked, as participants who are habitually more active and typically have higher-quality sleep perform better in cognitive tests.

1

Learning Accelerators @learningaccelerators.com · Dec 12

6/10
They also quantified sleep duration and time spent in lighter (rapid eye movement, or REM) sleep and deeper, slow-wave sleep. The team adjusted for a wide variety of factors that might have distorted the results.

1

Learning Accelerators @learningaccelerators.com · Dec 12

5/10
The research team looked at data from 76 men and women who wore activity trackers for eight days and took cognitive tests each day.The data was used to determine how much time participants spent being sedentary, doing light physical activity, and doing moderate or vigorous physical activity.

1

Learning Accelerators @learningaccelerators.com · Dec 12

4/10
Less time spent sitting and six hours or more of sleep were also linked to better scores in memory tests the next day.
More deep (slow-wave*) sleep also contributed to memory function. This accounted for a small portion of the link between exercise and better next-day memory.

1

Learning Accelerators @learningaccelerators.com · Dec 12

3/10
A new study, just published in the International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity, found that, on average, people aged 50 to 83 who did more moderate to vigorous physical activity than usual on a given day did better in memory tests the day after.

1

Learning Accelerators @learningaccelerators.com · Dec 12

2/10
Previous research in a laboratory setting has shown that people's cognitive performance improves in the hours after exercise, but how long this benefit lasts was unknown.

1

Learning Accelerators @learningaccelerators.com · Dec 12

The cognitive boost our brains get from exercise persists throughout the following day, a new study by researchers from University College London suggests!

A thread - 1/10
#cognition #neuroscience #memory #psychology #physiology #exercise

Couple walking in the countryside enjoying exercise

1 1 4

Learning Accelerators @learningaccelerators.com · Dec 10

10/10
Karre Sai Anirudh , Reddy Y. Raghu, Model-based approach for specifying requirements of virtual reality software products.
Frontiers in Virtual Reality 5, 2024

Frontiers | Model-based approach for specifying requirements of virtual reality software products

IntroductionGathering requirements for developing virtual reality (VR) software products is a labor-intensive process. It requires detailed elicitation of sc...

www.frontiersin.org

2

Learning Accelerators @learningaccelerators.com · Dec 10

9/10
There is a lot more interesting detail in the full research paper by Dr. Sai Anirudh Karre, PhD and Y. Raghu Reddy, below - freshly published in the journal 'Frontiers in VR'.

1 1

Learning Accelerators @learningaccelerators.com · Dec 10

8/10
VR authoring tools focus on clarity and conciseness, whilst requirement specification tools are designed to provide a more comprehensive approach to the management of requirements.

1 1

Learning Accelerators @learningaccelerators.com · Dec 10

7/10
Whilst VR authoring tools are designed for developing and organising content based on requirements, requirement specification tools are an evolving class of products for managing and tracking requirements throughout development.

1 1

Learning Accelerators @learningaccelerators.com · Dec 10

6/10
This uses a model-based approach to the specification of virtual reality software products which allows analysts to specify requirements for both simple and complex multi-scene VR software products and virtual environments (VEs).

1 1