Alex Holcombe
@alexh.bsky.social
5.8K followers 1.6K following 9.7K posts
Science-ing, trying to improve science. Cognitive and perceptual psychologist. Biases include @simine (💍), cats (🚫) Mastodon: @[email protected]
Posts Media Videos Starter Packs
alexh.bsky.social
There's no right answer here in my opinion because I think authorship is a confused muddle, but given the current system, let's say I recognize an opportunity to make a research project happen by dint of me contributing a whole lot of labor, but I then don't have time to contribute anything else.
alexh.bsky.social
About intellectual contribution being a criterion, It's almost elitist by definition, but focusing on that probably confuses the debate.
So, to start afresh, I'd be interested to know why you think (if you do) that only people who make intellectual contributions should be on the by-line.
alexh.bsky.social
Nice to know you agree with this one! Always interested to hear peoples' thoughts.
Reposted by Alex Holcombe
craft-oa.bsky.social
No matter where you are in the world🌍🌏🌎, you're invited to join the livestream for Monday's keynote speeches starting at 14:10 (CEST).

🎤Dr. David Oliva Uribe (UNESCO)

🎤Prof Dr Johan Rooryck & Pierre Mounier (European Diamond Capacity Hub)

www.craft-oa.eu/craft-oa-con...

#CRAFT_OA2025
alexh.bsky.social
And there are many scholarly communities using it that didn't need liberation because they were never captured. Notably, ironically, those in low and middle-income countries.
alexh.bsky.social
PKP is behind Open Journal Systems, the most widely-used free open source journal management system, which can be used to liberate us from Elsevier and all the rest of the profiteers! #openaccess
juancommander.scholcommlab.ca
JOB OPPORTUNITY: @pkp.sfu.ca is looking for a Managing Director! This is a rare opportunity to lead a highly impactful #scholcomm organization. Role works closely with me (Scientific Director) to provide strategic and operational leadership. Help us spread the word!

pkp.sfu.ca/2025/09/17/h...
PKP is hiring a Managing Director - Public Knowledge Project
The Public Knowledge Project, a Core Research Facility of SFU, invites applications for the position of Managing Director
pkp.sfu.ca
Reposted by Alex Holcombe
oabooksnetwork.bsky.social
EVENT: Join us at our next free webinar, 'Publishing Open Access Books: Insights from ERC-Funded Authors'

📆 Tuesday 30 September
⏰ 11am BST / 12pm CEST

Find out more & register: openaccessbooksnetwork.hcommons.org/2025/09/03/p...

#OAbooks @operaseu.bsky.social
An event card showing the details of the event that are given in the post. It also says 'An OABN webinar with the support of the ERC Executive Agency'.
alexh.bsky.social
Was great to get some answers to this, from ChatGPT (not kidding).
Australians are different; they never say "we're not here to fuck spiders, as it were" nor "he couldn't organise a piss-up in a brewery, as it were"
alexh.bsky.social
Seems that in some fields that is now semi-formally assumed to be the corresponding author. Of course, that's often the most senior author, who is most likely to be dead or retired, haha, by the time an investigation begins.
alexh.bsky.social
That's a good point. Going back to the original 1997 Rennie contributorship proposal, he and others were already saying that one/some authors should be declared "guarantor" and take the most responsibility. Do you have another idea?
alexh.bsky.social
Under a contributorship system, the people who wrote the paper would be listed as having written the paper, so authorship in that sense would continue. Contributorship is about not conflating authorship (writing) with other things involved. But I don't know if I understood your point right.
alexh.bsky.social
Authorship was invented for entities in which the only thing people really care about is who wrote it, like a book. A scientific paper is not about the words, but reports a project of work that can have many more people involved.
alexh.bsky.social
Right thanks, I just wanted to check that I hadn't missed something.
alexh.bsky.social
Is this a sarcastic comment, meaning that you don't think that people p-hack?
alexh.bsky.social
I don't get what you mean. I'm probably being thick here.
alexh.bsky.social
and including metadata in Acknowledgments, so that people like technicians in Acknowledgments sections can make it into scholarly databases.
alexh.bsky.social
I hadn't heard of "institution authorship", would love to read more about that!
Because contributorship isn't fully replacing authorship anytime soon, we are advocating for measures to improve tracking of who did what, including broader use of taxonomies like CRediT,
alexh.bsky.social
I favor contributorship, essentially as proposed by Rennie et al. in 1997
(some background here www.mdpi.com/2304-6775/7/... , www.nature.com/articles/d41...), which is just to have a list of the substantial contributors, indicating who did what.
www.mdpi.com
alexh.bsky.social
I don't recall seeing the word "professional" anywhere, did you mean that literally?
alexh.bsky.social
The seventh edition of the APA Publication Manual: “Authorship encompasses … not only persons who do the writing but also those who have made substantial scientific contributions to a study” (p. 24) which I like. www.apa.org/pubs/journal...
www.apa.org
alexh.bsky.social
I'm confused by what you mean... I wasn't proposing that the author list be condensed. Instead, primarily oriented toward saying who did what, and including all significant contributors in the "who".
alexh.bsky.social
(Please note: This year, ASPP2025 will happen just before the annual conference of the Australasian Cognitive Neuroscience Society, also in Melbourne. www.acns.org.au/conferences/...)
A great opportunity to attend two fantastic conferences.
Melbourne 2025 - Australasian Cognitive Neuroscience Society
www.acns.org.au
alexh.bsky.social
This conference is organised by the Australasian Society for Philosophy and Psychology (theaspp.org) via the Monash Centre for Consciousness and Contemplative Studies (www.monash.edu/m3cs)
The Australasian Society for Philosophy and Psychology
theaspp.org
alexh.bsky.social
They invite contributions from all subfields of cognitive science, neuroscience, psychology, philosophy and the areas in between.
I'll be there! :)
The Australasian Society for Philosophy and Psychology
theaspp.org
alexh.bsky.social
The Australasian Society for Philosophy and Psychology 2025 Conference will be held at Monash University (Caulfield Campus) 24-25 Nov.
That's just before the Australian Cognitive Neuroscience Society, also in Melbourne!

Abstract submissions open until 1 October: sites.google.com/monash.edu/a...
ASPP 2025 Melbourne
Australasian Society for Philosophy and Psychology 2025 Conference Melbourne, November 24th - 25th, 2025
sites.google.com