Thanks, now did find it. Saw the essay many times but not the rubric. To be honest, using that rubric I probably would not have given the student a zero, except for the 10 points for engagement with the article. But not a passing grade, to be sure.

Was the assignment ever posted like the essay was? Was there a rubric? Unsure how to interpret this without the relevant facts.

You've come far, Pilgrim.

I am embarrassed at how many times my husband and I have scoured the DirecTV channels to find a Dirty Harry film. Too many brain cells committed to random dialogue and scenes.

Here's how to do it.

Once They Moved Like the Wind by David Roberts.

OMG, me too. I still remember seeing that episode when it aired. My Dad about fell out of his chair laughing. I love that joke so much.