Based on a Book Podcast
LightNews LightNews
banner
basedonabook.bsky.social
Based on a Book Podcast
@basedonabook.bsky.social
2.4K followers 520 following 1.5K posts
Three book besties read, watch, and review film adaptations of your favorite books. ❤️🔪🛸🧚🔎🌶️👩‍🔬 https://beacons.ai/basedonabookpodcast
Posts Replies Media Videos
basedonabook.bsky.social
Want the full deep dive? Don’t miss the episode! We unpack every character across all versions, spill our favorites, and—of course—include full spoilers for the story we can’t stop talking about. 🎧

💙📚🖋️⏰ 🎬🎥
#books #bookish #romance #classics #janeausten #prideandprejudice #movies #television
BOOK VS ADAPTATIONS The book gives the sharpest wit, deepest internal character journeys, and slowest burn. The 1995 series is the most faithful, detailed, and closest to Austen's intent. The 1940 film delivers classic Hollywood charm with major story changes. The 2005 film is the most cinematic, emotional, stylistically modern. ¥PiE PREJUDICE BOOK THOUGHTS Reading Pride and Prejudice together gave all three of us wildly different, but equally enthusiastic, experiences. For Keri, this was her first full read of the novel, even though she's practically memorized the 2005 movie. She went in expecting a dense, intimidating classic and ended up absolutely loving it. She deep-dived into every detail and backstory to fully understand the world, and the payoff was huge. With its lively cast, clashing personalities, romantic tension, heartbreak, scandal, and all the complicated rules of Regency society, this book felt like a true accomplishment and one of her favorite reads of the year. Lindsey had only ever read bits and pieces back in high school, so this was her first full, intentional read as an adult. While the 19th-century language took a little getting used to, she was completely swept up in the story. The romance made her giddy, the tension between Elizabeth and Darcy fed her soul, and the emotional payoff hit just right. She thought it was beautiful, charming, and endlessly fun. Crystal, our resident Austen devotee, loves Jane Austen's entire body of work. And while she still thinks this novel is brilliant, she's also honest: the pacing can drag and the sheer number of subplots can make it feel a bit long in places. It isn't her personal favorite of Austen's catalog, but she still finds the writing sharp, the character work brilliant, and the story iconic. @BASEDONABOOKPODCAST THOUGHTS ON THE MOVIES & SERIES For this episode, each of us took on a different Pride & Prejudice adaptation, and somehow managed to fall in love with all three for totally different reasons. Keri took on the 1995 BBC miniseries and instantly understood why it's so beloved. Faithful, detailed, and luxurious in pacing, this version gives the story room to breathe, and gives viewers more of the Elizabeth-and-Darcy dynamic she lives for. It captured the heart of the book while delivering even more nuance, depth, and chemistry. PRIDE TRUDICE PRIDECPREJUINCE RIDI CARSON-OLIVIER Lindsey watched the 2005 film and fell completely in love with it. She adored its cinematic beauty, emotional intimacy, and modern romantic energy. From the atmosphere to the casting to the visual storytelling, this adaptation swept her away. Crystal dove into the 1940 film, a version she found surprisingly charming. While the story takes creative liberties and leans heavily into comedy, she still had a great time watching it. And in a shocking twist of fate, she may have discovered a new favorite Mr. Darcy. Once a steadfast Matthew Macfadyen stan, Crystal is now questioning everything thanks to Laurence Olivier's suave, old-Hollywood Darcy. @BASEDONABOOKPODL FINAL VERDICTS Which was better: the book or adaptation? While she loved reading the book for the first time, Keri couldn't resist the BBC series. Its rich detail, lengthy runtime, and faithful adaptation gave her more of what she wanted-more Elizabeth, more Darcy, and more emotional payoff. The series delivered the slow-burn depth her heart craved Lindsey adored the book, but the 2005 movie stole her heart. Its dreamy cinematography, intimate emotional tone, and gorgeously modern romantic energy made the story feel even more magical. It's the version that made her swoon from start to finish. Crystal enjoyed the 1940 movie for its charm and humor but preferred the novel by far. Jane Austen's writing, character depth, and emotional nuance shine brightest in the book. To her, nothing beats the original wit, structure, and storytelling. @BASEDONABOOKPODCAST
December 9, 2025 at 6:03 PM
basedonabook.bsky.social
Emma is so enjoyable! There are some great movies and shows adapted from it, too!
December 8, 2025 at 3:10 PM
basedonabook.bsky.social
Which adaptation is your favorite, and which one are you adding to your watchlist or TBR next? 💕📺📖

💙📚🖋️⏰ 🎬🎥
#books #bookish #romance #classics #janeausten #prideandprejudice #movies #television
Pride, Prejudice and Mistletoe (2018 movie) In a gender reversal, Darcy is a wealthy businesswoman who returns to her hometown for Christmas to help her mother plan a charity event. There, she reconnects with her old high school rival, Luke Bennet. Pride. Unmarriageable: A Novel by Soniah Kamal A retelling of Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice set in Pakistan during the 2000s. PRIDE AND PREJUDICE IN PAKISTAN Unmarriageable A NOVEL SONIAH KAMAL Eligible by Curtis Sittenfeld A modern retelling of Pride and Prejudice set in Cincinnati, Ohio. Fire Island (2022 movie) Fire Island reimagines the Bennets as an LGBTQ+ found family who go on annual vacations together to the titular island. Noah decides to help his friend, Howie, hook up with a nice guy named Charlie. However, they find themselves being judged by Charlie's social circle, including his friend Will, an antisocial lawyer. Despite Noah and Charlie's mutual dislike, they can't help but be drawn to each other throughout the film. @basedonabookpodcast Pride and Prejudice Atlanta (made for TV movie) Pride & Prejudice: Atlanta transplants the story to Atlanta, Georgia, and features a predominantly Black cast. In this version, Lizzie is a local activist fighting gentrification while Mr. Darcy is a rich politician running for Congress. While Lizzie is quick to judge Darcy for his connections to the very developers she's been fighting, she unwittingly inspires him to make better use of his money and position so he can help the community. basedonabookpodcast
December 8, 2025 at 3:01 PM
basedonabook.bsky.social
Today we’re celebrating the Austen Adaptation Multiverse with a roundup of retellings, reimaginings, and wildly creative takes inspired by the Bennet sisters and everyone’s favorite problematic-then-perfect gentleman.

💙📚🖋️⏰ 🎬🎥 #bookish #classics #janeausten #prideandprejudice #movies #television
Bridget Jones's Diary (2001 movie) A modern retelling of Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice. It stars Renee Zellweger as Bridget Jones, a 30-something single woman in London. The Lizzie Bennet Diaries (2012 series) Modern vlog-style retelling of Pride and Prejudice focusing on the Bennet sisters, their romantic entanglements with wealthy suitors Bing Lee and the enigmatic Darcy, and their mother's efforts to marry them off. Bride and Prejudice (2004 movie) A modern adaptation of Jane Austen's classic novel, Pride and Prejudice, that features the lives of four unmarried daughters in an Indian family. Lost in Austen (2008 series) Amanda, an ardent Jane Austen fan, lives in present day London with her boyfriend Michael, until she finds she's swapped places with Austen's fictional creation Elizabeth Bennet. @basedonabookpodcast Unleashing Mr. Darcy (2016 movie) In this modern day spin on "Pride & Prejudice," Elizabeth Scott (Cindy Busby), is fishing for direction in her life and gets the opportunity to professionally show her Cavalier King Charles Spaniel in a fancy New York dog show. Austenland (2013 movie) Obsessed with Pride and Prejudice (1995), a woman travels to a Jane Austen theme park in search for her perfect gentleman. basedonabookpodcast
December 8, 2025 at 2:58 PM
basedonabook.bsky.social
It’s really interesting to see how the tone of the stories can shift for different audiences, and to imagine how the world was at the time they were released. We can’t wait to do this more! 🎥🎬💙📚
December 6, 2025 at 5:19 PM
basedonabook.bsky.social
Next up Emma and Clueless??? 💙📚🎬🎥
December 5, 2025 at 6:09 PM
basedonabook.bsky.social
You know we couldn’t pass that by!
December 4, 2025 at 1:07 PM
basedonabook.bsky.social
All three hosts agreed Jamie Dornan stepped up BIG in this film, Dakota Johnson brought Ana to life in a way the book didn’t & the character development (especially Ana’s) worked so much better on screen. And yes—we talk about why this story absolutely did not need to be 500+ pages. 🙈

💙📚🌶️🎬🎥
BOOK THOUGHTS Fifty Shades Darker As a group, we walked away from Fifty Shades Darker feeling overwhelmed, underwhelmed, and a little confused about how the same book managed to do both. All three of us agree on one big thing: there is a lot happening in this book. Lindsey especially felt like she was juggling five subplots at once. With so many threads pulling for attention, it was hard to settle into any single storyline long enough to stay invested. She's convinced she would've rated it higher if the book had simply focused more and tried to do a little less. EL James Crystal, who found the first book so bad it was good, didn't get that same fun energy this time. For her, this book wasn't delightfully messy, it was just messy. Keri had a very different experience-at least the first time around. When she originally read this series, it was her introduction to erotica and she loved it. But rereading it now, after years of reading a wide range of spicy romances, this book did not hold up. She felt the relationship development between Ana and Christian was weak, and that all the added subplots existed mostly because their dynamic wasn't interesting enough on its own. She hoped this reread would rekindle her old love for the series, but instead it left her disappointed. And across the board, we all agreed: There are too many spicy scenes, and most of them don't serve the story. They re frequent, repetitive, and rarely move the plot forward, which only adds to the overcrowded feeling of the book. @BASERONABOOKPODCAST MOVIE THOUGHTS All three of us agree that Jamie Dornan is significantly stronger in this second film. His performance feels more confident, more grounded, and honestly, more human. Movie-Christian finally has a personality beyond brooding stares and one-word answers, which is a major step up from his book counterpart, who often feels flat and one-track-minded. Dakota Johnson also shines here. She gives Ana a sense of realism, emotional logic, and growth that the book doesn't quite pull off. Movie-Ana gets an actual are, and Dakota's performance makes her feel like a real person rather than a blank slate reacting to Christian's demands. That said, the movie swings a little too far in the other direction with Christian. Compared to the slow, uneven development in the book, the film's version feels almost over-corrected-he evolves rapidly, sometimes unrealistically fast. But honestly? We'll take an overly developed Christian over the underwritten, personality-deficient version we get in the novel. We all agreed the movie does streamline the story in ways that work. But it does cut some major conversations, especially around contraception and mental health-important topics that deserved screen time. Still, the film's focus and pacing make it far more enjoyable than the overlong, 500+ page book that often feels padded with unnecessary scenes. @BASEDONABOOKPODCAST BOOK VS MOVIE Fifty Shades Darker EVERY FAIRY TALE HAS A DARK SIDE EL James FIFTYSHADES DARKER Both the Fifty Shades Darker book and movie follow Ana and Christian as they reunite, confront figures from Christian's past, and begin navigating a deeper, more emotional relationship. But the two versions take very different routes in how they deliver the drama, tension, and backstory. The book leans heavily into And's work life, her dynamic with Jack Hyde, and the growing threats surrounding Christian's past. It also gives more insight into Ana's inner thoughts and Christian's controlling behaviors, making the relationship complications feel more layered. Several characters have expanded roles with more detailed backstories and motivations. There's also more emphasis on Christian's financial The movie streamlines the plot, shifting the spotlight toward Ana and Christian's emotional reconnection and Christian's trauma. Some character arcs and reveals are simplified or altered. The film incorporates more of Christian's childhood background earlier and uses visual storytelling to show his vulnerability rather than lingering on relationship negotiations or workplace drama. Several book subplots and details are trimmed or combined to keep the pacing fast and cinematic. The book is heavier on relationship complications, emotional introspection, and external conflict, while the movie focuses more on romance, redemption, and visual tension. Both tell the same love story-but each version chooses a different path to get there. @BASEDONABOOKPODCAST FINAL VERDICT In the end, we unanimously prefer the movie over the book. Better performances, clearer character arcs, stronger pacing, and fewer pointless subplots make this adaptation the more compelling version of the story. Fifty Shades Darker EVERY FAIRY TALE HAS 1 DARK SIDE FIFTYSHADES DARKER EL James Full Episode Available on Podcast Platforms & YouTube YouTube @BASEDONABOOKPODCAST
December 2, 2025 at 2:07 PM