Charlie Methven
@charliemethven.bsky.social
230 followers 89 following 410 posts
I set cryptic crosswords as Methuselah and Chameleon and write questions for Only Connect • charliemethven.com • he/him
Posts Media Videos Starter Packs
charliemethven.bsky.social
Can I interest you in today's Independent cryptic? 🎭
charliemethven.bsky.social
It will make a nice change for there to be a Welsh woman named Charlotte in the castle #TheTraitors
charliemethven.bsky.social
Cheers. Glad you enjoyed it!
charliemethven.bsky.social
Yeah I don't think you're gonna be able to negotiate with a runaway zebra mate
charliemethven.bsky.social
@ecclescrosswords.bsky.social cheers for the re-bleet, Andy. Sorry for nicking your slot!
charliemethven.bsky.social
Just don't let Spooner get his hands on that phrase
charliemethven.bsky.social
Royal property unequally divided between Regan and Cordelia (7)
from a 2023 Methuselah
charliemethven.bsky.social
And lest we forget H from Steps - Hyperactive
charliemethven.bsky.social
Does HIGNFY still do use a guest publication for the guess the headlines game?
charliemethven.bsky.social
Well they were obviousy very interested in cricket score cards once upon a time! This is where I think the fairness of a single source of abbreviations has to be balanced with the unfairness, misbalance of references etc which that bakes in
charliemethven.bsky.social
Maybe not hyper, but Guinevere had the good example of Association earlier. If you say uber-common component abbreviations *should* be in the dictionary, then one might say there's no harm in using clear omissions like that (though personally I think it'd be neater to stick to standalones)
charliemethven.bsky.social
On "fun" I think there's a comparison to be drawn between Chambers and VAR in football which is supposed to ensure fairness, but regularly leads to results that instinctively feel wrong because either a corker of a goal is disallowed or a boring technicality is allowed
a man wearing a yellow shirt with the letter i on the front
ALT: a man wearing a yellow shirt with the letter i on the front
media.tenor.com
charliemethven.bsky.social
I'd feel very little guilt for using any of those 😁
charliemethven.bsky.social
Maybe what I mean is that it makes it a game played with the dictionary itself rather than a game played with the language where the dictionary is an honest referee. The ref's taking bungs to put B=British in there!
charliemethven.bsky.social
Not necessarily suggesting we all stop using B=British, just observing there's an arbitrariness to it which I find aesthetically(?) weak even if it's ethically(??) fair. Seems a bit like using "fridge" as an anagrind because, say, Chambers accidentally listed it as a synonym of drunk
charliemethven.bsky.social
I agree "they're in the dictionary" is useful when you need a binary way to decide fair/not fair (competitions etc). But given that we have no time for *new* standalone ones, the original non-standaloners which stowed away in Chambers almost seem tantamount to mistakes
charliemethven.bsky.social
Yeah, which would be a nightmare! I'd argue the likes of B=British would never make it in if you were drawing up a list specifically for this purpose and re-evaluating each abbrev on the same merits an upstart abbreviation like V=Vegetarian is judged on
charliemethven.bsky.social
G=group/group of as in G8 etc another good example of that I think. And yes I think I remember a rookie on BD who'd got the same impression as your friend
charliemethven.bsky.social
(Thank you to the government of Benin for sponsoring this table)
charliemethven.bsky.social
Thinking about abbreviations. Some from the top right quadrant occasionally break through as we acknowledge Chambers is often behind the times. But given no-one supports the bottom right, is there any real justification for bottom left other than "they're in the dictionary" and we're used to them?