podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/i...

Try this one

A local friend tells me that the SNA member talking sounds like he has a Turkmen accent from around Aleppo, but it's not clear.

The wounded men are likely Arabs and 'self defence' could refer to HXP, the conscript/national service force of AANES.

Very rough translation:

SNA: Who are you? Army? How long are you fighting?
W1: Well what can we do, we had to.
SNA: And you? (to W2). You're army or PKK?
W2: Self defence, border guard
SNA: When were you shot?
W2: Yesterday

Then they execute both

This absolutely does not mean that the city can hold out indefinitely, but it is a huge morale boost, proves that the SDF have learned important lessons from 2018-19 wars, and crucially shows that a multi-ethnic force can work effectively together under extreme pressure.

Pro-Turkish sources are still claiming that the city has fallen while Manbij Military Council members are freely moving about filming videos of the streets absolutely littered with SNA dead.

...committed by Islamists since the fall of ISIS, amongst others the near-total ethnic cleansing of Afrin and now Shebha region of Kurds and other ethnic minorities. If Manbij is taken we will likely see a repeat of the rape, torture and brutal executions still ongoing in Shebha.

Heyva Sor a Kurdistanê e.V.

Kreissparkasse Köln

IBAN: DE49 3705 0299 0004 0104 81

BIC/SWIFT: COKSDE33XXX

Reference: Rojava

PayPal: [email protected]

Our attention now should turn to Minbij. SNA seem to be intent on taking it, and a lot will come down to what Turkey decides. I suspect there is a lot of negotiation going on between Russia, Turkey and US about this, as so far Turkish Airforce have been quite restrained.

Summary:

I don't think NW Syria has been quite the failure for SDF as being portrayed online, but at the same time I think there is very real chance there is humanitarian tragedy playing out that we won't be aware of until more evacuees arrive in SDF areas and can share info.