Lightnews — Scholar-powered news

Reposted by Tim O'Neill - History for Atheists

Dan McClellan @maklelan.bsky.social · 9d

Responding to an outdated mythicist claim
#maklelan2923
youtube.com/shorts/4gm8Q...

Responding to an outdated mythicist claim #maklelan2923

YouTube video by Dan McClellan

youtube.com

7 58

Reposted by Tim O'Neill - History for Atheists

Dan McClellan @maklelan.bsky.social · 10d

I recently had the privilege of talking with Tim O'Neill for his show, History for Atheists, and the episode is out now. You can check it out here:

www.youtube.com/watch?v=P7kS...

Dan McClellan - The Hebrew Bible

YouTube video by History for Atheists

www.youtube.com

1 38

Tim O'Neill - History for Atheists @timoneill.bsky.social · 10d

Just uploaded to the History for Atheists channel, my conversation with Dr Dan McClellan @maklelan.bsky.social
on the Hebrew Bible, its texts, contexts and misconceptions.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=P7kS...

1 16

Tim O'Neill - History for Atheists @timoneill.bsky.social · 29d

… - Peter Heather’s recent book is vastly superior and without the weird biases. It’s also funny she keeps bravely sniping at me from behind a block. Such fortitude.

Tim O'Neill - History for Atheists @timoneill.bsky.social · 29d

Wow, she’s resorted to the feeble “he’s a Christian apologist” tactic already? 🤣 And all I did was comment on the overblown pre-publicity and her Nixey-style crap from the past. Three chapters in and all I can say about the book is it seems a bit pointless. Real historians have done it better …

1

Tim O'Neill - History for Atheists @timoneill.bsky.social · 29d

Who is going to give me “both barrels” over what exactly? The person above has me blocked, so if they want to engage with me they’re going about it rather strangely. 🤔

1

Tim O'Neill - History for Atheists @timoneill.bsky.social · Sep 7

Yes. You’d think if the Great Professor was confident in her ideas she’d engage with her critics. And sniping at them from behind the safety of a block is doubly feeble.

3

Tim O'Neill - History for Atheists @timoneill.bsky.social · Sep 7

I see. So, as you’ve shown, I merely commented on her past form, noted a couple of things about the pre-publicity and reserved judgement about the book. Contrary to what she claimed.
I’m currently four chapters in and so far find it pretty unremarkable, though her odd biases are clear.

Tim O'Neill - History for Atheists @timoneill.bsky.social · Sep 7

She’s got me blocked (she’s *very* sensitive to any kind of criticism and has a hair trigger on blocking even the mildest dissent). So what were you quoting me in response to “for the record”?

1

Tim O'Neill - History for Atheists @timoneill.bsky.social · Sep 7

Okay, I’ll post a link here. My comments were on her previous behaviour, bad historical takes and the pre-publicity for the book though, so I fail to see the problem with any of that.

1

Tim O'Neill - History for Atheists @timoneill.bsky.social · Aug 21

Please go to Please go to igg.me/at/bartonhfa... and contribute whatever you can. All contributors will be acknowledged and thanked by name at the end of the show. Thanks in advance.

Bart Ehrman on History for Atheists

Help fund Bart Ehrman's speaker's fee so he can appear on History for Atheists. | Check out 'Bart Ehrman on History for Atheists' on Indiegogo.

igg.me

Tim O'Neill - History for Atheists @timoneill.bsky.social · Aug 21

... for appearances like this. So any contribution you can make toward the US$2000 this will cost would be much appreciated. Bart is going to be my final guest on HIstory for Atheists, so I hope you can help bring the channel to a fitting finale.

1

Tim O'Neill - History for Atheists @timoneill.bsky.social · Aug 21

The good news is that Prof. Bart Ehrman has agreed to appear on the History for Atheists video channel and podcast for a 1-2 hour conversation about Jesus Mythicism, the historical Jesus and his Jewish apocalyptic context.
As Bart is a busy man, he charges as speaker's fee ...

1 1

Tim O'Neill - History for Atheists @timoneill.bsky.social · Aug 21

Help make it happen - help raise the speaker's fee so Bart Ehrman can appear on History for Atheists on
@indiegogo Help make it happen - help raise the speaker's fee so Bart Ehrman can appear on History for Atheists on
@indiegogo

1 3 6

Tim O'Neill - History for Atheists @timoneill.bsky.social · Aug 6

So the latest addition to my Great Myths series covers how this idea of an eternal conflict between science and religion arose, why it persists and who keeps propping it up. Enjoy.

1 7

Tim O'Neill - History for Atheists @timoneill.bsky.social · Aug 6

New on History for Atheists: The Great Myths 16 - The Conflict Between Science and Religion.
If there is a foundational myth that underpins a great deal of anti-theist bad history, it's the notorious Conflict Thesis.
historyforatheists.com/2025/08/the-...

1 3 14

Tim O'Neill - History for Atheists @timoneill.bsky.social · Aug 2

What’s that got to do with atheist activists’ misconceptions about the Old Testament?

1

Tim O'Neill - History for Atheists @timoneill.bsky.social · Aug 1

The key words above are "things ATHEISTS get wrong about the Hebrew Bible etc."

Tim O'Neill - History for Atheists @timoneill.bsky.social · Aug 1

My next interview on the History for Atheists channel will be with Dr Dan McClellan ‪@maklelan.bsky.social‬ on things atheists get wrong about the Hebrew Bible/OT, early Jewish beliefs, the history of ancient Israel etc. What would you like me to ask Dan about?

4 1 15

Tim O'Neill - History for Atheists @timoneill.bsky.social · Jul 21

Orestes was a Christian. Pretty much everyone on both sides were Christians. I just looked at your profile and you seem unhinged. Time to ignore you I think.

Tim O'Neill - History for Atheists @timoneill.bsky.social · Jul 21

My *what*? You seem like a loon.

1

Tim O'Neill - History for Atheists @timoneill.bsky.social · Jul 21

And “corrected” by who? Who should be held accountable for a political faction fight in an ancient city 1600 years ago? What the hell are you talking about?

1

Tim O'Neill - History for Atheists @timoneill.bsky.social · Jul 21

More fantasy. Please read some actual historians on what happened, particularly in the context of the social and economic divisions in the city. Her murder had nothing to do with religion.

2

Tim O'Neill - History for Atheists @timoneill.bsky.social · Jul 20

… aligned with Christian thinking (several of her students were leading Christians) and continued to be so. Hypatia as a “martyr” to anything is a modern fairy tale.

1

Tim O'Neill - History for Atheists @timoneill.bsky.social · Jul 20

She was murdered in a political faction fight over hierarchy and authority in the city that had nothing to do with religion or philosophy. Our most contemporary source even says she was caught up in “political jealousies” *despite* her renown as a philosopher. And Neoplatonism was already closely…

1