Thank you!

Completely missed that one I confess! Will check it out.

Not many of the reviewed authors are on here, but thanks to @hannahfrydman.bsky.social @rmesch.bsky.social @carolinesequin.bsky.social for their amazing work. Please tag anyone I missed.

I remember being so excited for this game when it came out but concensus wasn't too into it. How's it hold up?

Sure happy to share. It's mostly an in class activity so the handout is pretty basic but I can also show you the spreadsheet. Just dm me your email and I'll send it along next time I'm at my computer.

I do a comparative textbook activity, where I give small groups the chapters of the French Revolution from various Western Civ textbooks and have them fill out a spreadsheet with various basic questions, some of which will be different, but not wrong (when did it start? end? Who participated?)

No I'm not. But I also think accuracy is important. As far as I know the aha hasn't laid out guidelines for the use of generative Ai in professional research.

No which is why I'll be continuing to ban it. I actually find this list of useful cases useful insofar as it is also a list of Ai use cases that I need to help students understand why it's not helpful. Regardless I think it's important to put the chart into its proper context

I don’t think that’s entirely case since I don’t expect my students to have all the skills I do. I build in shortcuts for them into my assignments. On the flip side, while I do not intend on ever using generative ai in my research I do think I’ll have to address it in my methods class.

the teaching report says to expect one on research as well.

Since the report itself was more pro ai than I think most historians on blue sky including myself. I think it was foolish of them to include that chart with frankly bizarre suggestions.

For what’s its worth, this chart isn’t a set of research guidelines. Unless folks are screenshotting a new report, it is from the @historians.org teaching guidelines. The chart was meant to demonstrate a possible classroom policy, not a recommended policy. I am not surprised that it is being misread

Lol

Have you considered that perhaps you’re not entirely objective when it comes to this subject?