Amanda Weiss
@amandaweiss.bsky.social
1.2K followers 430 following 290 posts
Assistant Professor, Cornell Department of Government. Political methodology, policy, and meta-science. www.amandakweiss.com Opinions my own, reposts not (necessarily) endorsements, etc.
Posts Media Videos Starter Packs
Pinned
amandaweiss.bsky.social
🚨 Updated working paper!

Ekin Dursun and I ask what instruments best manipulate emotions on surveys (osf.io/56h4g).

We find that vignettes really work! They have large effects on emotions of interest & smaller effects on emotions *not* of interest.

But as always, it's complicated.👇

(1/17)
Abstract of a paper written by Amanda Weiss and Ekin Dursun and titled "Robust Emotion Manipulation for Surveys: Evidence from Three Experiments."

The abstract reads: "A large number of experiments investigate the effects of emotions on critical political outcomes, including policy attitudes, support for authoritarians, tolerance, and political participation. The success of these experiments depends on emotion manipulations: Manipulations must be strong enough to shift one target emotion while also being specific enough shift other confounders only minimally. In this project, we identify emotion manipulations that fulfill these imperatives. First, using causal graphs, we show that in such experiments, emotions are intermediate outcomes of randomly assigned emotion manipulation instruments—not randomized treatments themselves. Then, we present evidence from three experiments (total N = 6, 649) on the effectiveness of vignettes, autobiographical emotional memory tasks, images, and more for inducing anger, gratitude, fear, political anger, political gratitude, and political cynicism. We show that vignettes are reliable instruments in terms of both strength and specificity. We also investigate compliance with emotion manipulation instruments and find that pre-treatment attitudes toward research may moderate treatment effects.
amandaweiss.bsky.social
I'm tempted to hustle over to a mall and start checking out tags.
amandaweiss.bsky.social
I wonder if these types of labels serve as an information treatment for Americans.

In general, economic voting does not depend on accurate blame attributions - just people taking out grumpiness on incumbents. But does anything change if Trump voters connect higher prices to tariffs?
sjrickard.bsky.social
If this price differential for a high-street brand skirt is due to US #tariffs, it suggests a tariff pass-through rate of 100%, controlling for the exchange rate. But of course, there could be other factors at play.
amandaweiss.bsky.social
Matt, it genuinely really shaped how I thought about estimand selection. I quoted that tweet on my quant methods qualifying exam in grad school. 😂
amandaweiss.bsky.social
Just dug up this banger of a @mattblackwell.bsky.social post to use in my instrumental variables slides.

Pumped to be teaching the next generation about choosing estimands based on identification assumptions. 😂🙏
amandaweiss.bsky.social
Okay, follow-up on the students' first grades of the semester.

On the one hand: *So many* Calendly sign-ups.

On the other hand: it feels like a huge teaching win that one of my students told me this morning that they were disappointed in their grade, but also understood it based on my comments.
Baby clenching handful of sand; image known as the "Success Kid" meme
amandaweiss.bsky.social
I was skeptical of Vancouver APSA.
But I just posted my first grades of the semester from JFK and maybe another country is the right place to be headed after giving some folks what could be their first-ever sub-A grades.
amandaweiss.bsky.social
There is, unfortunately, a precedent of sorts. Trump sent in the National Guard to D.C. after Edward "Big Balls" Coristine was assaulted by some teenagers
guygrossman.bsky.social
The pretense for WWI was the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand. The pretense for the 1982 Lebanon war was the PLO's attempted assassination of Israel's ambassador to the UK, Shlomo Argov.

So, yeah, this tragic assassination may not end well.
Reposted by Amanda Weiss
zackbeauchamp.bsky.social
Very, very bad stuff coming from leading right-wingers
amandaweiss.bsky.social
Tom understands the assignment.
amandaweiss.bsky.social
I have yet to find a way to incorporate the bear-skinning episode into my observational causal inference course, but I have until Monday.
amandaweiss.bsky.social
For my political behavior writing seminar, I assigned a "pastiche op-ed," where the students have to use current events as the hook for an opinion column... I'm making them all use the bear.

I look forward to reading a lot of op-eds about hunting regulation written in the voice of Maureen Down.
amandaweiss.bsky.social
(I checked first that none of my students could possibly have been the students involved in the original incident.)
amandaweiss.bsky.social
For my political behavior writing seminar, I assigned a "pastiche op-ed," where the students have to use current events as the hook for an opinion column... I'm making them all use the bear.

I look forward to reading a lot of op-eds about hunting regulation written in the voice of Maureen Down.
amandaweiss.bsky.social
Definitely! But maybe there is a question here about whether pre-reg has value prospectively (nudging researchers to do better research with thoughtful hypotheses) or just retrospectively (giving readers/reviewers the chance to see if a paper is good or bad).
Reposted by Amanda Weiss
smotus.bsky.social
John Oliver: "While get the appeal of thinking just one more concession, one more payoff might safeguard your independence or let you live to fight another day, it's worth asking at what point have you compromised so much that
the thing you're supposed to be defending is gone."
Trump vs. Higher Education: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO)
YouTube video by LastWeekTonight
www.youtube.com
amandaweiss.bsky.social
I'm mostly kidding, but there are in fact models for indoctrination in political science research! I once heard Don Green describe training graduate students as, essentially, creating disciples to spread the causal inference gospel across the globe.
amandaweiss.bsky.social
Sometimes when I look at the state of research credibility innovations, I wonder if what we really need is a civic virtue for the scholarly community...
amandaweiss.bsky.social
I am a HUGE pre-registration booster. But IMO this is the biggest problem with pre-reg (especially pre-reg without analysis plans): It's hackable if people pre-reg anything and everything.

Like I've heard people *brag* about having the foresight to pre-register a lot of hypotheses. Don't do that!
jbakcoleman.bsky.social
They can preregister the shit causal model or protocols, etc and it’s really important not to emphasize the lack of preregistration as credibility reducing because in doing so we’ll give it credibility when they prereg some “both go up” model.
amandaweiss.bsky.social
Is it too much to suggest a workshop or group brainstorm on generative AI, either in research or the classroom? I feel like all the best ideas and insights I've heard on the topic have just come from chatting with colleagues in the discipline!
amandaweiss.bsky.social
An underrated part of being from Indiana is being duty-bound to love all things Chicago.
amandaweiss.bsky.social
I mean, I like Chicago's special take on pizza, why not Chicago's special take on digestifs?
amandaweiss.bsky.social
The bartender at the JAWS happy hour last MPSA tried to convince me to order Malort. And I kind of wimped out. But now I'm curious!
Reposted by Amanda Weiss
chanda.blacksky.app
I refuse to give em dashes to the AI