Lightnews — Scholar-powered news

Charley Hasted @charleyhasted.bsky.social · 9d

Anyway I feel like I'm hitting the point of "I can't logic you out of a position you didn't logic yourself into." and that you're determined to not actually do anything but try and make the same point in a different way over and over. So have a nice afternoon and I'm out.

Charley Hasted @charleyhasted.bsky.social · 9d

But if you want to go through every single statute and piece of common law for the last 1000 years or so and make all the terminology used align then I'm sure they'd love to hear from you...

Charley Hasted @charleyhasted.bsky.social · 9d

If you have the PC of GR then you should be treated as your identified gender- just like anyone else. Gender and Sex have been used interchangeably in English and Welsh Law for ages as terms have gone and out of fashion (just as 'He' is interpreted as 'a person'). To do anything else creates chaos

1

Charley Hasted @charleyhasted.bsky.social · 9d

And this is my major problem here- this law is 15 year old. Most of the people involved are still alive. Many are still actively involved in the political life of this country. Getting the answer from the horses mouth would have required a 2 minute walk across parliament square.

1

Charley Hasted @charleyhasted.bsky.social · 9d

If they didn't put it in the EqA it's a fair bet they didn't want it to happen. But we also have statements from people involved in drafting the act that say the Supreme court judgement is wrong about their intention. But for some reason nobody thought to ask them.

1

Charley Hasted @charleyhasted.bsky.social · 9d

They put in caveats where they intended that the GRA would not be the last word on the matter or where it would. That's why you can exclude trans women from women's services in some cases. It's why you needed a GRC to have the right gender on your wedding certificate.

1

Charley Hasted @charleyhasted.bsky.social · 9d

It is, in fact, the kind of overly simplified assessment I would have been embarrassed to make in my 1st year let alone as a Supreme court judge precisely because it completely ignores that that interrelationship also effectively indicates the will of parliament.

1

Charley Hasted @charleyhasted.bsky.social · 9d

Yes and it renders the interrelationship of quite a number of pieces of law so utterly impossible that if it had been the intention of parliament then many many people were grossly incompetent.

1

Charley Hasted @charleyhasted.bsky.social · 9d

They're not sweeties. We don't 'offer' them to anyone. People can apply for them *if* they define as women but they don't have to. I know women who won't apply for AWS because they think it's tokenistic- are they not women?

Charley Hasted @charleyhasted.bsky.social · 9d

So are you deliberately laying false trails to try and stoke anger, mistrust and hatred towards trans people or talking about things outside your scope of competence?

1

Charley Hasted @charleyhasted.bsky.social · 9d

But you claim to be a barrister and therefore should be aware that you don't actually *have* to have a GRC to protected under the PC of Gender Reassignment and that GRC's fall under the category of types of information you'd need to have a damn good reason to ask to see anyway.

3

Charley Hasted @charleyhasted.bsky.social · 9d

Favours? No. Treats equally to? Yes.

But frankly the GRC question is just shorthand for "tell us about your genitals." And you'll note I did answer that. This is the thing about the Internet you can't gaslight people as easily because I can see exactly what I wrote.

1 2

Charley Hasted @charleyhasted.bsky.social · 9d

But realistically apply some logic here. What possible benefit would someone have to transition if they were lying about it?
Identify me 1 singular thing they would get access to that would make their life easier that couldn't be achieved with much less effort by NOT transitioning?

Charley Hasted @charleyhasted.bsky.social · 9d

1) We have the ability to use AWS if we want to (under the provisions of the Equality Act) to address a gender imbalance.

2) Nobody, Cis or Trans, 'claims' to be a woman. But no we don't ask people what their genitals look like before we let them stand for us which is what you're actually asking.

2 1

Charley Hasted @charleyhasted.bsky.social · 9d

I mean me either. But they know it's going to happen. They know the majority of the membership doesn't feel like they do. But presenting it like some grandee arbitrarily went "We're just not discussing this" is at best utterly disingenuous and at worst frankly manipulative.

1

Charley Hasted @charleyhasted.bsky.social · 9d

They had to lose TWO votes for it to happen, one of which happened after they put (presumably) their best arguments forward. If their *best* argument couldn't persuade 34% of people voting with them to stop the move to next business why would spending another half hour on it make a difference?

1 3

Charley Hasted @charleyhasted.bsky.social · 9d

This isn't being talked about- in order for us to Move to next business there is a procedure.
-75 word statement on why people want to talk about moving to next business.
-A vote to hear the case for and against. (Simple majority)
-Speech in favour
-Speech against
-Vote (2/3s majority)

1 3

Charley Hasted @charleyhasted.bsky.social · 9d

There wasn't a row. There was a debate, which they lost by a margin of more than 2 to 1, because they wanted to change our constitution to exclude trans people and our members said they weren't interested in doing that so rather than waste half an hour of everyone's lives let's carry on.

1 3

Reposted by Charley Hasted

Lib Dem Women @libdemwomen.bsky.social · 14d

We, the Liberal Democrats only official women's group, wholeheartedly stand by the amazing Woman that Cllr Chris Northwood is.

She is an inspiration to many within the party with her dedication to the party and her constituents.

She is a very deserving winner.

Liberal Democrats @libdems.org.uk · 14d

The Express asked us about awarding the Patsy Carlton Prize to Cllr Chris Northwood. We responded:

"This prize acknowledged an exceptional woman in Cllr Chris Northwood. The message it sends to women members and voters is that the Liberal Democrats honour and value all of our women members."

1 33 84

Charley Hasted @charleyhasted.bsky.social · 15d

"Oh running away are you?"
"Oh sweetie the only bit of me that runs is my nose."
----
He also tried to insult me by going "this man/woman/whatever they are."
Which frankly is a shit insult when you're non-binary and you gender identity is mostly 'confusion to my enemies!'

1 1 16

Charley Hasted @charleyhasted.bsky.social · 15d

Got harassed by a little gang of right wingers outside Lib Dem conference. They really picked on the least intimidatable 3 people.

"Are you connected to the Lib Dems?"
"Not physically."
--
"Where are the 50k jobs for illegals going to come from?"
*cackling*
"Oh you think that's funny?"
"Yes."

1 3 14

Charley Hasted @charleyhasted.bsky.social · 15d

K but not a journalist so not sure why they're relevant...

2

Charley Hasted @charleyhasted.bsky.social · 15d

Thank you!

2

Charley Hasted @charleyhasted.bsky.social · 15d

Opera, The Royal Albert Hall (it's complicated because it's an awesome building but the accessibility is utter drawers), kedgeree

3

Charley Hasted @charleyhasted.bsky.social · 15d

Of course if it's anything to do with trans rights you can't keep them out the room...

Almost like it's not about supporting women but rather persecuting trans people.

1 46