jb manchak
@manchak.bsky.social
100 followers 65 following 9 posts
I am a professor of Logic and Philosophy of Science at UC Irvine. I think about space and time. https://sites.socsci.uci.edu/~jmanchak/
Posts Media Videos Starter Packs
Pinned
manchak.bsky.social
"The universe is unknowable even if one were given an all-access pass to every possible observation at every possible place and time -- here, there, past, present, and future."
#physics #philsky #philsci

iai.tv/articles/the...
The universe is unknowable from within it | JB Manchak
iai.tv
manchak.bsky.social
Haha. Symmetry buddies are really hard to find -- hang in there!
manchak.bsky.social
Among other things, we show that the claim must fail for "Heraclitus" spacetimes -- models that have no local symmetries at all.
manchak.bsky.social
It is sometimes claimed that the "privileged coordinates" of geometric model (e.g. a relativistic spacetime) encode its "structure". In a paper just out in Philosophy of Science (open access), Thomas Barrett and I explore the limitations of this idea...

www.cambridge.org/core/journal...
What Do Privileged Coordinates Tell Us about Structure? | Philosophy of Science | Cambridge Core
What Do Privileged Coordinates Tell Us about Structure? - Volume 92 Issue 3
www.cambridge.org
Reposted by jb manchak
thebjps.bsky.social
New issue out now! Featuring evolutionary transitions and cumulative culture, hole arguments and jury theorems, Galileo’s ship and best laid plans, distinguishing the indistinguishable, and so much more…

Read it here: www.journals.uchicago.edu/toc/bjps/202...

#philsci #philsky #hps
BJPS, Volume 76, Issue 2
Table of Contents

‘Evolutionary Transitions in Individuality’, by Pierrick Bourrat

‘Closing the Hole Argument’, by Hans Halvorson & J B Manchak

‘Jury Theorems for Peer Review’, by Marcus Arvan, Liam Kofi Bright & Remco Heesen

‘On the Objectivity of Measurement Outcomes’, by Elias Okon

‘Consensus versus Unanimity: Which Carries More Weight?’, by Finnur Dellsén

‘Mere Recurrence and Cumulative Culture at the Margins’, by Sebastián Murgueitio Ramírez & Nicholas J Teh

‘Normative Formal Epistemology as Modelling’, by Joe Roussos

‘How to Distinguish between Indistinguishable Particles’, by Michael te Vrugt

‘Best Laid Plans: Idealization and the Rationality–Accuracy Bridge’, by Brett Topey

‘What Are the ‘Levels’ in Levels of Selection? ‘, by Markus Eronen & Grant Ramsey
manchak.bsky.social
Two new papers out today on "determinism" co-authored with the foundations of (a)symmetries dream team: @jimweatherall.bsky.social, Hans Halvorson, and Thomas Barrett. #philsci #philsky

philsci-archive.pitt.edu/24881/

philsci-archive.pitt.edu/24883/
Determinism and Asymmetry in General Relativity - PhilSci-Archive
philsci-archive.pitt.edu
manchak.bsky.social
"The universe is unknowable even if one were given an all-access pass to every possible observation at every possible place and time -- here, there, past, present, and future."
#physics #philsky #philsci

iai.tv/articles/the...
The universe is unknowable from within it | JB Manchak
iai.tv
Reposted by jb manchak
ucisocsci.bsky.social
UC Irvine's Department of Logic & Philosophy of Science earns top spots in latest faculty rankings | Philosophical Gourmet Report’s 2024-25 update places @ucirvine.bsky.social faculty among the top in the English-speaking world for faculty excellence

www.socsci.uci.edu/newsevents/n...
UC Irvine’s Department of Logic & Philosophy of Science earns top spots in latest faculty rankings
www.socsci.uci.edu
manchak.bsky.social
New paper "On Privileged Coordinates and Kleinian Methods" just published online at Erkenntnis (joint work with Thomas Barrett). We investigate senses in which the "privileged coordinates" of a geometric space might have significance.

link.springer.com/article/10.1...
On Privileged Coordinates and Kleinian Methods - Erkenntnis
This paper examines two ways in which the ‘privileged coordinates’ of a geometric space might have significance. First, the structure of the space might be ‘determined by its privileged coordinates’. ...
link.springer.com
manchak.bsky.social
"Heraclitus-Maximal Worlds" was just published in the Journal of Philosophical Logic (joint work with Thomas Barrett). Bumper sticker version:

Einstein spacetime + Heraclitus asymmetry + Leibniz maximality = no empirical underdetermination
Journal of Philosophical Logic | Volume 53, issue 6
Volume 53, issue 6 articles listing for Journal of Philosophical Logic
link.springer.com