Ben Collier
@susansegfault.bsky.social
2.6K followers 1.9K following 130 posts
Senior Lecturer at University of Edinburgh in STS. Criminologist and author of Tor: From the Dark Web to the Future of Privacy. Chair of the Foundation for Information Policy Research. Researching power and harm in digital infrastructure. Pfp Jamie Buchan
Posts Media Videos Starter Packs
Pinned
susansegfault.bsky.social
For any lovely people who haven't heard, or aren't totally sick of me going on about it, my book on @torproject.bsky.social - bizarrely, the first book to tell the secret history of the technology behind the so-called 'dark web' - is out. Buy here or any bookstore: mitpress.mit.edu/978026254818...
Tor
A biography of Tor—a cultural and technological history of power, privacy, and global politics at the internet's core.Tor, one of the most important and mi...
mitpress.mit.edu
Reposted by Ben Collier
drhannahgraham.bsky.social
Jamie Buchan, Sarah Anderson, and Katrina Morrison have published a 'Criminal Justice in Scotland' textbook 📚🍷📖👏

I had the joy of chairing their well attended book launch today.

It has gone straight onto #Criminology Uni reading lists.
🔗
www.routledge.com/Criminal-Jus...
@kmmorrison.bsky.social
Photo of one of the three book authors, Dr Jamie Buchan, signing a copy of his new book for someone who just bought it at the book launch in Edinburgh Napier University. Photo of two copies of the paperback book with a red cover and black inky silhouette imagery.
Reposted by Ben Collier
meredithmeredith.bsky.social
📣 Germany's close to reversing its opposition to mass surveillance & private message scanning, & backing the Chat Control bill. This could end private comms-& Signal-in the EU.

Time's short and they're counting on obscurity: please let German politicians know how horrifying their reversal would be.
signal.org
We are alarmed by reports that Germany is on the verge of a catastrophic about-face, reversing its longstanding and principled opposition to the EU’s Chat Control proposal which, if passed, could spell the end of the right to privacy in Europe. signal.org/blog/pdfs/ge...
signal.org
Reposted by Ben Collier
fipr-policy.bsky.social
Has this all be throught through. In short, this has all the makings of another fiasco like the Post Office scandal. People will be wrongly denied access to basic services, employment, and other aspects of day to day life when this all breaks down.
Reposted by Ben Collier
fipr-policy.bsky.social
On the BritCard - in theory better government systems are a great idea, but implementing it requires very high levels of management competence to cope with the ambition and complexity; the costs will correspondingly be very high.
Reposted by Ben Collier
fipr-policy.bsky.social
Systems like this need real institutional legitimacy to work.
Reposted by Ben Collier
fipr-policy.bsky.social
The other countries where this kind of digital ID has been implemented are far smaller, and don’t have our appalling track record of expensive government IT disasters.
Reposted by Ben Collier
fipr-policy.bsky.social
There are absolutely real cybersecurity risks as well - not least, from the people with legitimate access to the system. For example, every year more than half of the prosecutions under the Computer Misuse Act are of serving police officers caught misusing their access to police databases.
Reposted by Ben Collier
fipr-policy.bsky.social
Linking together all these different government systems and databases and tying them to a single point of truth about you - the obsession of the Tony Blair Institute - is going to be incredibly complicated, and is a disaster waiting to happen.
Reposted by Ben Collier
fipr-policy.bsky.social
This isn’t just about ID - most people have some form of ID, and digital ID systems can be designed well and preserve our privacy and basic rights. It’s about the particular design of this system and what they want to achieve with it.
susansegfault.bsky.social
Nominal popular support for SOME kind of digital ID v different to support for this specific system brought in by this specific government. Would be interesting to see if the polling being thrown around for ID card popularity is the same in a month once the policy irrevocably associated w/ Starmer.
Reposted by Ben Collier
susansegfault.bsky.social
When combined with the ‘sex-based’ papers please approach being trailed by Streeting for public institutions, this has the potential to be a massive further clampdown on access to public life for trans people in the UK
Reposted by Ben Collier
susansegfault.bsky.social
Also important to ask - how will trans people, ever the punching bag of this govt and the assembled UK press, be represented in this single point of truth about the data self?
susansegfault.bsky.social
www.theguardian.com/politics/202... This is an extremely dangerous idea to propose right now. We can argue on civil liberties and privacy aspects, but the one thing systems like this need is institutional legitimacy, something that the UK’s media and political elite have been torching in recent yrs.
Keir Starmer expected to announce plans for digital ID cards
As government looks for ways to tackle illegal immigration, move will spark battle with civil liberties campaigners
www.theguardian.com
Reposted by Ben Collier
ubisurv.net
On why the #UK #LabourParty is increasingly looking like an arm of US platform capitalism...
susansegfault.bsky.social
When combined with the ‘sex-based’ papers please approach being trailed by Streeting for public institutions, this has the potential to be a massive further clampdown on access to public life for trans people in the UK
susansegfault.bsky.social
Also important to ask - how will trans people, ever the punching bag of this govt and the assembled UK press, be represented in this single point of truth about the data self?
susansegfault.bsky.social
www.theguardian.com/politics/202... This is an extremely dangerous idea to propose right now. We can argue on civil liberties and privacy aspects, but the one thing systems like this need is institutional legitimacy, something that the UK’s media and political elite have been torching in recent yrs.
Keir Starmer expected to announce plans for digital ID cards
As government looks for ways to tackle illegal immigration, move will spark battle with civil liberties campaigners
www.theguardian.com
Reposted by Ben Collier
medconfidential.bsky.social
It’s Labour’s conference week, so the Government is announcing digital ID cards and re-announcing its politically-controlled centralised database of all of your medical notes.

medconfidential.org/2025/single-...
Single Patient Record (and ID cards…) | medConfidential
medconfidential.org
Reposted by Ben Collier
susansegfault.bsky.social
Also hard to see a ‘Brit card’ going down particularly well in the devolved nations.
Reposted by Ben Collier
susansegfault.bsky.social
The attempt to link this to a nationalist and frankly racist border politics in particular is liable to simultaneously double down on the anti immigrant rhetoric of Reform and conspiracist far right narratives playing off the real issues of UK surveillance overreach.
Reposted by Ben Collier
susansegfault.bsky.social
www.theguardian.com/politics/202... This is an extremely dangerous idea to propose right now. We can argue on civil liberties and privacy aspects, but the one thing systems like this need is institutional legitimacy, something that the UK’s media and political elite have been torching in recent yrs.
Keir Starmer expected to announce plans for digital ID cards
As government looks for ways to tackle illegal immigration, move will spark battle with civil liberties campaigners
www.theguardian.com
Reposted by Ben Collier
torproject.org
The Tor Project has joined the Rust Foundation as an Associate Member! Read the announcement to learn more about our investment in the Rust Project: rustfoundation.org/media/rust-f...
Reposted by Ben Collier
zarahsultana.bsky.social
Labour’s plan for compulsory digital ID risks creating a more authoritarian state.

Under constant surveillance, we would have to pass through digital checkpoints just to live our daily lives — with even more barriers for minorities, migrants and the digitally excluded.
susansegfault.bsky.social
Also hard to see a ‘Brit card’ going down particularly well in the devolved nations.