Ken Holstein
@kenholstein.bsky.social
980 followers 370 following 9 posts
HCI Prof at CMU HCII. Research on augmented intelligence, participatory AI, & complementarity in human-human and human-AI workflows. thecoalalab.com
Posts Media Videos Starter Packs
Reposted by Ken Holstein
mlam.bsky.social
LLM safety work often reasons over high-level policies (be helpful & polite), but must tackle on-the-ground cases (unsolicited money advice when stocks are mentioned). This can feel like driving on an unfamiliar road guided by a generic driver’s manual instead of a map. We introduce: Policy Maps 🗺️
Reposted by Ken Holstein
aolteanu.bsky.social
There is a lot of talk and effort to figure out how genAI is different (I am also guilty of this!) -- the reality is that genAI is not that different and genAI is not that new either; it was hard to evaluate in the past, and it is still as hard to evaluate now #facct2025
Reposted by Ken Holstein
katestarbird.bsky.social
Somewhat oddly, the Trump regime's initial moves to cut science funding went very broad. This is catalyzing solidarity & advocacy around the value of science (see comms featuring cancer cures & tech innovation). But their next move may be to try to drive a wedge b/w "good science" & "bad science".
Reposted by Ken Holstein
altcdc.altgov.info
Securing your phone before entering the USA. 🧵
At CDC we travel around the globe to confront health threats and have never worried about returning home. Yet more researchers, including US Citizens, are having their phones searched at Customs.

security.ucop.edu/resources/tr...
Returning to the U.S.
security.ucop.edu
Reposted by Ken Holstein
chrislhayes.bsky.social
Unidentified men grabbing someone off the street and putting her in a car because she wrote an op-Ed. This as flatly authoritarian as anything we’ve seen in this country in a very long time.
paleofuture.bsky.social
Video of the international student at Tufts being arrested by "federal authorities" in Massachusetts has been released and it's terrifying.

They're not even uniformed officers. Just secret police thugs in hoodies and masks.

From WCVB: youtu.be/PuFIs7OkzYY
Reposted by Ken Holstein
himself.bsky.social
1. @alisongopnik.bsky.social, Cosma Shalizi, James Evans and myself have a new piece in Science on "AI" Large Models, pushing back against much of the collective wisdom about what they can and can't do. Official below, unpaywalled at henryfarrell.net/large-ai-mod... . So why this now?
Large AI models are cultural and social technologies
Implications draw on the history of transformative information systems from the past
www.science.org
Reposted by Ken Holstein
tskuo.bsky.social
How can we help communities collaboratively shape policies that impact them?

In our #CHI2025 paper, we present PolicyCraft, a system that supports ✨collaborative policy design✨ through case-grounded deliberation.

(🧵/11)
ACM CHI 2025
PolicyCraft: Supporting Collaborative and Participatory Policy Design through Case-Grounded Deliberation
Tzu-Sheng Kuo, Quan Ze Chen, Amy X. Zhang, Jane Hsieh, Haiyi Zhu, Kenneth Holstein
Reposted by Ken Holstein
uhleeeeeeeshuh.bsky.social
How can we better think and talk about human-like qualities attributed to language technologies like LLMs? In our #CHI2025 paper, we taxonomize how text outputs from cases of user interactions with language technologies can contribute to anthropomorphism. arxiv.org/abs/2502.09870 1/n
Image of the first page of the CHI 2025 paper titled "A Taxonomy of Linguistic Expressions That Contribute To Anthropomorphism of Language Technologies" by authors Alicia DeVrio, Myra Cheng, Lisa Egede, Alexandra Olteanu, & Su Lin Blodgett
Reposted by Ken Holstein
shannonmattern.bsky.social
"18F works just how Musk + team pretend that they want gov't to work. But when his team found it, they destroyed it. 18F’s work is evidence that gov't works well, which undermines their msg that it doesn’t. 18F’s parent agency, the [GSA], turns a profit as an agency. So it has to be destroyed too."
Requiem for 18F
A small government unit did what DOGE is pretending to do
donmoynihan.substack.com
Reposted by Ken Holstein
raelinm.bsky.social
#Pittsburgh friends, Join me on Friday #standupforscience2025. Our city will be devastated if our universities lose critical funding. Our universities are top 10 employers, the entire city’s economy is dependent on science funding. www.eventbrite.com/e/stand-up-f...
Stand Up for Science 2025 - Pittsburgh, PA
Stand up for science with us on March 7th, 2025, because science is for everyone! More info at www.standupforscience2025.org
www.eventbrite.com
Reposted by Ken Holstein
anna-kawakami.bsky.social
🏛️ How can we ensure that AI enhances, rather than harms, public services?

In our policy memo, published with the Federation of American Scientists (@scientistsorg.bsky.social), we provide recommendations for how the fed gov't could help state & local agencies make better AI procurement decisions.🧵
Expanding Local Government Capacity for AI Procurement and Use
As new waves of AI technologies continue to enter the public sector, touching a breadth of services critical to the welfare of the American people, this center of excellence will help maintain high st...
fas.org
Reposted by Ken Holstein
pbahners.bsky.social
Joseph Ura: “A president refusing to abide by the law or the Constitution and ignoring court orders to stop his illegitimate actions would be a constitutional crisis like a bank robbery is a cash flow crisis.” www.theatlantic.com/newsletters/...
‘Constitutional Crisis’ Is an Understatement
It’s the hottest, and most useless, buzz phrase of the moment.
www.theatlantic.com
Reposted by Ken Holstein
ldburnett.bsky.social
for pity’s sake, I am BEGGING university leaders to stop framing this issue in terms of what this will cost the university. people dont care!

EXPLAIN WHAT THIS WILL COST THE PUBLIC: closed hospitals and clinics, skipped treatments, loss of access to experimental drugs, unemployment, recession
sreenshot from the new york times reporting that Stanford University’s provost is talking about how the loss of funding from national institutes of health funding will cost the university $160 million. that’s not the way to get this changed — the people think “stanford is rich; no big deal.” leaders need to talk about what this will cost the public
Reposted by Ken Holstein
rawx.bsky.social
"AI ... becomes a tool for replacing politics. The Trump administration frames generative #AI as a remedy to 'government waste.' However, what it seeks to automate is not paperwork but democratic decision-making."
Reposted by Ken Holstein
katestarbird.bsky.social
Scientists and journalists need to figure out right quick how to explain to the average person how a massive change in research indirects will impact the medical care they and their children get (eg at the local children’s hospital), the education their children will get, the price of tuition, etc.
Reposted by Ken Holstein
himself.bsky.social
What I should have done in the beginning - here's a starter pack of 20-odd experts who journalists or others might want to read/talk to to understand the gutting of the administrative state (as opposed to broad decline of democracy etc). I've focused on academics go.bsky.app/MaC7vnv
Reposted by Ken Holstein
davidimiller.bsky.social
First off, it's critical to note:

NSF is CONGRESSIONALLY MANDATED to evaluate proposals via broader impacts, as defined by this law below.

Hence, if the admin wants NSF to deviate, that's called **breaking the law** (important to remind Congress of that)

www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/...

2/5
Reposted by Ken Holstein
spavel.bsky.social
I'm an adventurous eater, but even I draw the line here
Sandwich at Whole Foods labeled "Lorem Ipsum Dolor & Cheddar"
Reposted by Ken Holstein
randomwalker.bsky.social
Bitter Lesson¹ maximalists seem to ignore the distinction between AI capability improvement and AI-based product development. When it comes to the latter, the Bitter Lesson has never been true, and it would be silly to suggest that it is.

¹ www.incompleteideas.net/IncIdeas/Bit...
The Bitter Lesson
www.incompleteideas.net
Reposted by Ken Holstein
devezer.bsky.social
Alright it's here! Where we push back against the exploratory-confirmatory distinction that's become canonized in metascience and talk about what we think exploratory research (including exploratory experimentation and modeling) means and why our view is incompatible with 'unplanned data analyses'.