Jake Wright
@bcnjake.bsky.social
2K followers 320 following 850 posts
Philosopher, husband, dad, teacher, "leftist," potty-mouth, and pedagogical chaos agent. Aspiring to be the C.M. Punk of higher education. Distinguished, or so I'm told. he/him
Posts Media Videos Starter Packs
Pinned
bcnjake.bsky.social
"There's no ethical use case for AI in the classroom" has become my personal Carthago delenda est.

I even take time to explain to my students how we won't use it in class because it's dehumanizing. To their credit, they seem to get it.

CETERUM AUTEM CENSEO INTELLIGENTIA ARTIFICIALIS ESSE DELENDAM
AI is dehumanizing

I’ve saved the most important part for last. AI is dehumanizing. Using AI means saying that the people involved in what you’re trying to do don’t matter. Because AI platforms are built on theft, using AI says that the people whose work is being stolen don’t matter. If I used AI to grade your work, which is now possible with Canvas integrations, I would be saying your work is not worth taking seriously enough to read myself. It’s saying you don’t matter enough to take seriously. A world where AI grades AI generated submissions from an AI generated assignment is not a world where people and the work they do matters, and I refuse to live in that world.

The dehumanizing aspect of AI is even worse when you consider the effects of AI on you as a student. Using AI as a substitute for doing the work yourself robs you of your voice. It prevents you from developing your own sense of who you are, what you believe, and how you express that in your own unique way and replaces it with statistically generated slop literally incapable of forming a novel thought. In a world that works to dehumanize us every day—to say who we are and the relationships we form don’t matter—I don’t want to add to that work. I don’t want to do this because the relationships you form matter. Your voice matters. You matter.

In 19th Century England, a group of artisan weavers banded together to fight against mechanization. Tools like the water frame and spinning jenny allowed factory owners to produce a worse product at a price so low that the quality of the finished product didn’t matter. These artisans, the Luddites, weren’t opposed to technology. They were opposed to technology dehumanizing people and denying them dignity. Like the Luddites, I’m not opposed to technology and embrace it when it makes our lives better. But like the Luddites, I have an obligation to resist technology that dehumanizes people in my community, and I think AI does that. So, there’s no AI in this class.
bcnjake.bsky.social
These guys (and they’re *always* guys) are either hardcore anarchists or hardcore libertarians. They’re committed to Rationality, which is to say that anyone who disagrees with them is either unreasonable or too stupid to see their brilliance. They’ve read one philosophy book and misunderstood it.
bcnjake.bsky.social
Peter Thiel is that annoying-ass kid in your Intro to Philosophy class who thinks they have it all figured out and are just in the room to have their brilliance confirmed. They’re in every intro class, are universally insufferable, and think failure to understand their gibberish is your fault.
sharonk.bsky.social
thiel, man, what the fuck are you talking about
bcnjake.bsky.social
Peter Thiel is that annoying-ass kid in your Intro to Philosophy class who thinks they have it all figured out and are just in the room to have their brilliance confirmed. They’re in every intro class, are universally insufferable, and think failure to understand their gibberish is your fault.
sharonk.bsky.social
thiel, man, what the fuck are you talking about

He describes the plot of Watchmen, a 1986 graphic novel involving superheroes grappling with moral questions about humanity against the backdrop of impending nuclear war:

The antihero Ozymandias, the antichrist-type figure, is sort of an early-modern person. He believes this will be a timeless and eternal solution – eternal world peace. Moore is sort of a late-modern. In early modernity, you have ideal solutions, ‘perfect’ solutions to calculus. In late modernity, things are sort of probabilistic. And at some point, he asks Dr Manhattan whether the world government is going to last. And he says that ‘nothing lasts forever.’ So you embrace the antichrist and it still doesn’t work.

Thiel later finds biblical meaning in the manga One Piece, discussing how he believes it represents a future where an antichrist-like one-world government has repressed science. He believes that the hero, Monkey D Luffy, represents a Christlike figure.

In One Piece, you are set in a fantasy world, again sort of an alternate earth, but it’s 800 years into the reign of this one-world state. Which, as the story unfolds, gradually gets darker and darker. You sort of realize, in my interpretation, who runs the world and it’s something like the antichrist. There’s Luffy, a pirate who wears a red straw hat, sort of like Christ’s crown of thorns. And then towards the end of the story, transforms into a figure who resembles Christ in Revelation.

Thiel, along with a researcher and writer at Thiel Capital, explored these ideas at greater length in an essay for the religious journal First Things earlier this month.
bcnjake.bsky.social
Tell me you’ve never met Presbyterians without telling me you’ve never met Presbyterians.
Reposted by Jake Wright
clairewillett.bsky.social
if you’re not Catholic, let me real quick tell you about the breathtaking audacity of bringing the monstrance with him

a monstrance is a big bedazzled gold ornament with a round glass window in the middle where you put a consecrated wafer, usually the bigger ceremonial one and not the bite-size
Reposted by Jake Wright
clairewillett.bsky.social
found exactly the one use of “evil recoils in the presence of Christ” I am willing to sign off on, HOOOOOOOOLY SHIT

Father Larry did not come here to fuck around
richraho.bsky.social
Chicago priest Fr. Larry Dowling describes procession to ICE facility: “No one had the courage to speak directly to us. No one from Homeland Security could stand in the presence of the Monstrance holding the Blessed Sacrament. No wonder. Evil is repelled, recoils in the presence of Christ.”
bcnjake.bsky.social
I don't care if you work in the ICE cafeteria.

Hague.
kenwhite.bsky.social
Also: if you work for ICE, even if you’re not one of the ones arresting citizens or tackling 15-year-olds or zip-tying kids together and segregating them by race, you’re part of the mechanism making it happen, and you should suffer long-term social and post-regime-change consequences.
aricohn.com
Some weirdo on Twitter has been absolutely melting down for like 36 straight hours because I posted:

When this is over, do not forget what ICE did, and what ICE is. And do not make room for them in society. Make sure they know that they are, and will continue to be, reviled and beneath contempt.
bcnjake.bsky.social
I'm saying this as someone who genuinely *loved* Tron: Legacy. Ares underwhelming at the box office is simple.

It's a nostalgia play, but Ares is the third Tron movie. The THIRD.

If Tron was part of your childhood, you're pushing FIFTY. This is not a "blow the doors off the theater" demographic.
charliejane.bsky.social
I'm perplexed at watching pundits in the trades struggling to explain Tron Ares' disappointing opening.

Was it covid? Do people just not like science fiction? etc. etc.

The main reason is pretty obvious: Tron isn't a popular franchise. Nobody's interested in nostalgia for a failed 1980s project.
bcnjake.bsky.social
He's weirdly understated on 30 Rock. Like, so understated it's a bit unnerving.
bcnjake.bsky.social
Humans go to the Grid: Dope AF

Programs come to the Real World: Dopey AF
bcnjake.bsky.social
Also, the moral of every single Tron movie is "please be as precise as possible when giving programming instructions."
bcnjake.bsky.social
Of all the movies I've ever seen, Tron: Ares was certainly one of them.
bcnjake.bsky.social
Like Michael Sheen eating so much scenery in Legacy you'd think it was part of a balanced diet.
bcnjake.bsky.social
Of all the movies I've ever seen, Tron: Ares was certainly one of them.
bcnjake.bsky.social
Were there any inflatable frogs?
bcnjake.bsky.social
Is that a baseball game or an anti-ICE protest?
bcnjake.bsky.social
Or anything, really. Passing your grading off to AI is simply deciding that your students’ work isn’t worth engaging with. And if that’s how you feel, why on Earth are you in a classroom?
biblioracle.bsky.social
I strongly urge everyone to not just read this warning from @marcwatkins.bsky.social, but heed it, and be vocal and forceful pushing back against using AI to grade student writing. This must be anathema if we're going to have a world where learning means something. substack.com/inbox/post/1...
The Dangers of using AI to Grade
Nobody Learns, Nobody Gains
substack.com
bcnjake.bsky.social
My 5YO was playing Minecraft on the Xbox, casually pulled up Spotify, threw on some music, and went back to Minecraft like it was second nature. FIVE.
bcnjake.bsky.social
Can I add to this quickly as an NTT?

Yes it’s scary and everything being described in thread is real. BUT MANY OF US ARE OUT HERE DOING THE WORK ANYWAY because it’s the right thing to do. The fact that we, the least protected, are showing this kind of bravery while many admins don’t is infuriating.
Reposted by Jake Wright
lmacthompson1.bsky.social
Our classrooms are not safe for us or regular students. Our universities canot be relied upon to protect us. You have to keep speaking up about this. Faculty already are, but we need folks who aren’t in academia raising the alarm for everyone else. The End.
bcnjake.bsky.social
I want whatever the columnist who thought “The man who wrote ‘The Ballad of Ira Hayes’ and made the video for ‘Hurt’ was deeply square and never countercultural” is smoking.
bcnjake.bsky.social
Found a customer for Dennis Leary’s Coffee-Flavored Coffee!
Reposted by Jake Wright
ditzkoff.bsky.social
Donald trump can still win the Nobel Peace prize if Mike Pence has the courage
Reposted by Jake Wright
davelevitan.bsky.social
This morning there is one Nobel Peace Prize winner, 8.1 billion or so people who did not win the Nobel Peace Prize, and one Nobel Peace Prize loser.