#circularreasoning
I need home prices to stay high so that I can inherit it, and use that money to buy my kids their own homes.

#CircularReasoning #StuckOnTheCarousel
Every single day, I'm told that home prices have to stay high since seniors rely on that equity to fund their retirement.

The evidence that this is true, however, is remarkably thin. Yet it's something that's nearly universally treated as true.
November 1, 2025 at 3:17 PM
The Atheist Experience 29.36 with Forrest Valkai and Justin 2025-09-07
In today’s thought-provoking episode of The Atheist Experience, Forrest Valkai and Deconstruction Zone Justin dive into the persistence of bad arguments, the misinterpretation of scientific findings, and the profound impact of beliefs on personal and societal well-being. Rook in NY posits that belief in God isn't inherently bad, suggesting that in a "perfect world," individuals could hold such beliefs privately without negative consequences. Justin and Forrest counter that religious beliefs inevitably influence behavior and policy, citing historical examples of religiously motivated oppression and arguing that even private beliefs can hinder personal growth and societal progress, as beliefs don't stay in a vacuum. Rook ultimately acknowledges his point's shortcomings upon deeper scrutiny. What are the broader implications of beliefs that remain unchallenged? Simone in United Kingdom presents a syllogism, arguing that if thoughts are part of reality and we think God exists, then God exists as part of that reality. The hosts challenge this, asking if imagining a creature means it truly exists, and if this is a genuine reason for belief or a fear of hell. Simone reveals she is still in the early stages of deconstructing her Christian upbringing and has more questions than answers. How does one navigate a deconstruction journey when fundamental beliefs are questioned? Brisbane in AZ questions satanic atheism, claiming an AI overview suggests it promotes self-indulgence and a rejection of altruism. Forest refutes this by reading the Satanic Temple’s actual tenets, which include compassion and justice, and critiques Brisbane's reliance on inaccurate AI summaries over primary sources. The discussion highlights the dangers of trusting AI for complex information and the importance of critical thinking in evaluating belief systems. What role should AI play in informing one's understanding of complex philosophical or religious concepts? Robert in GA challenges the hosts on Jesus's fulfillment of Old Testament prophecies and asserts that the complexity of life necessitates a creator, claiming the Big Bang violates thermodynamics. Justin explains how Robert's cited prophecies are taken out of context and not messianic, while Forest refutes the scientific claims, pointing to evolution and the accurate understanding of thermodynamics. The hosts urge Robert to engage with actual scientific and biblical scholarship rather than relying on misinformed arguments. How do individuals overcome ingrained misinformation when seeking truth? Hindu in India argues that consciousness, rather than emerging from the brain, is an ultimate reality of the universe, aligning with the Vedic concept of Brahman. Justin and Forest press for empirical evidence, pointing to how brain modifications alter personality, contradicting the idea of consciousness as an external driver. The hosts emphasize that materialism offers an evidence-based framework for consciousness, while idealism often relies on presuppositions. What scientific breakthroughs would truly bridge the gap between materialist and idealist views of consciousness? Robin in FL shares a family claim that a "spark of life" at conception, supposedly visible during horse breeding, proves the existence of a soul. Justin and Forest clarify that this "spark" is a scientific observation of zinc release during fertilization, not a visible soul, often misinterpreted from studies on mice. They question the logical extensions of this argument, such as mice having souls, and the implications for asexual reproduction. How do scientific findings become distorted and adopted into religious or spiritual narratives? Chris in KS raises the question of circular reasoning in Old Testament prophecies applied to Jesus, particularly Isaiah 7. Justin affirms this circularity, explaining that such prophecies often require secondary interpretations not supported by their original context, challenging the criteria for true prophecy. Forest then discusses gender, distinguishing it from sex as a fluid, socially constructed spectrum not bound by a binary, and encourages self-reflection for deeper understanding. How can an individual reconcile deeply held religious beliefs with evolving scientific and social understandings? Thank you so much Richard for being here thank you Forest and thank you crew we'll see you again next week uh same time same place 5:30 uh Eastern time 4:30 Central time bye!
www.spreaker.com
September 8, 2025 at 6:08 AM
The Supreme Court issued another barely-explained shadow docket ruling that essentially scolds lower courts for following actual precedent instead of reading the tea leaves of emergency orders.

#SCOTUS #Law #Trump #GOP #ShadowDocket #CircularReasoning #Precedent

www.techdirt.com/2025/07/24/s...
Supreme Court To Lower Courts: Ignore Actual Binding Precedent, Follow Our Unexplained Shadow Docket Vibes Instead
The Supreme Court’s shadow docket has become a lawless mess. The justices are issuing extremely consequential rulings with either no explanation at all, or with barely a paragraph of reasonin…
www.techdirt.com
July 25, 2025 at 2:29 AM
Government: "We're making bold progress!"
Citizens: "On what exactly?"
Government: "Being bold about progress!" #CircularReasoning #LuxPolitics
May 16, 2025 at 4:26 PM
I love this!
May 4, 2025 at 2:20 AM
Why #Religious People Can't Convert s | vs #Logic https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=En91uXI9PcA #circularreasoning #cult #christianity
#atheism#atheist#humanism#reason#religion#faith#god

👉 Atheist Vote!
April 28, 2025 at 1:29 PM
He's doing great because he says he's doing great. #CircularReasoning
"WEEK TEN WINS" - The White House.
Ten weeks into his second term, President Trump "keeps delivering transformative wins for the American people, empowering our workers, securing our nation, and cementing our leadership as the envy of the world"...
Pure madness.
www.whitehouse.gov/articles/202...
WEEK TEN WINS: President Trump Fuels America’s Golden Age
Ten weeks into his second term, President Donald J. Trump keeps delivering transformative wins for the American people — empowering our workers, securing
www.whitehouse.gov
March 29, 2025 at 6:20 PM
#BlueMagaCult proproganda talking point stolen from #RedMaga fight #AOC harder than Trump, freeze her out of leadership positions, then claim she doesn't do anything. #CircularReasoning this #WineCave #LimoLiberal would also say that MLK was just a "Talker" 🤦‍♀️🙄 Another White dude doesn't like POC 😳
February 27, 2025 at 7:28 AM
Say hello to "begging the question"! 🙃
#fallacy #circularreasoning
www.txst.edu/philosophy/r....
Begging the Question
www.txst.edu
January 13, 2025 at 6:36 PM
.@vg_nett har funnet ut at pelsdyroppdrett kan ikke forbys, fordi den er «en legal næring». Hæ? #CircularReasoning
http://www.vg.no/nyheter/meninger/dyrevern/nye-krav-til-dyrevelferd/a/23839324/
December 1, 2024 at 5:25 AM
They didn't test me for alcohol or drugs. So clearly I wasn't under the influence. #Zimmermandefense #circularreasoning
December 3, 2024 at 5:08 AM