elisa freschi
banner
elisafreschi.bsky.social
elisa freschi
@elisafreschi.bsky.social

Sanskrit (and) philosophy. Permanently in beta phase. Blogging at http://elisafreschi.com and http://indianphilosophyblog.org. Articles at PhilPapers Here to learn & share

Philosophy 47%
History 21%

For me, numbers tell me nothing (I have no way to know whether it's true and it costs you nothing to say it, since I do not have access to the letters you wrote for each other candidate in the last 20ys!).
Thoughts?
2/2

From a guidebook about #RecommendationLetters for law school: " "I recommend Jane with enthusiasm" tells us nothing. But, "in my twenty years here, I would place Jane in the top 3%" shines like a neon sign.”"

This is so much AGAINST my own experience with letters!
1/
"Unlike continental nonsense, analytic philosophy is clear and intelligible"

the changes in the light are really fascinating.

This is the kind of review that would cost me an enormous amount of time just correcting stupid mistakes, & I would end up feeling angry at myself for accepting it. I would still want to help a jr colleague or a recent post Doc, but it seems to me that a sr colleague should have higher standards
2/2

My latest rejection of a peer review:
I had a look at the article and I find a lot to disagree with even just in the bibliography (the primary texts are not even in alphabetical order; the list of secondary texts focuses mainly on the author himself, apart from quoting the same text by X twice).
1/

It's impressive to watch through your photos how Toronto decided to become uglier while not necessarily gaining new affordable flats.

A dictionary of Sanskrit philosophical terms (Sanskrit-French-English)
Jean-Marie Verpoorten, Répertoire des termes sanskrits des Ecoles philosophiques indiennes, Strasbourg, 2025, 751 p.

histoire.unistra.fr/websites/his...

#SanskritPhilosophy #philsky #philosophy
histoire.unistra.fr

I just read that Boris Oguibénine passed away in Strasbourg on November 12th—just days after celebrating his 85th birthday on November 6th.
He wrote on Vedic, Indo-European, Buddhist Sanskrit.

Hence, if these people behave in a certain manner and they see it as dharma and they are competent in dharma matters because of being well versed in the Veda, we can infer that their behaviour is based on the Veda. If not on the extant one, on some lost branches of it.
3/

Hence, if they do something in a given occasion which is not normed in the Veda, their action must be based on some Vedic text *we* have no access to. A Vedic text is inferred based on their behaviour.
2/

#Kumārila on sadācāra 'behaviour of good people' as a deontic source: The idea is that these people are well versed in the Veda and that the Veda is the only source for dharma.
1/
I will add the following: our students lack the research skills required to audit an LLM essay for errors. They don’t arrive on campus with these skills; we teach it to them over four long years. So throwing freshmen in the deep end and saying “swim your way to a shore of rectitude” is folly.

Reposted by Elisa Freschi

Reading #TheDarkForest and #TheDeathsEnd by Liu Cixin seems a long illustration of "timeo Danaos et dona ferentes" from Vergil's Aeneid.
#books

For Kumārila, we need both positive (reward if performed) and negative motivation (sanction if not performed) in the case of fixed/conditional duties (e.g., "Do X every single day, bc you're Y"). For elective duties, positive motivation is enough (perhaps because the reward is temporally close).

In Kumārila's ṬṬ, the metaphysical causality seems to be different. Elective rituals produce their result, like baking with flour, sugar and butter produces a cake. Fixed rituals, otoh, produce an apūrva, which —united to a varying number of other apūrvas— will lead to the result.

3)Any alternative explanation would need to be much more complicated (since it would need to explain why sth looks like it's the case although it isn't)
4)Therefore any alternative explanation would need to be justified, bc we (Mīmāṃsakas) don't accept complicated solutions unless they're needed
2/

According to #Kumārila:
1) We have cognitions of universals
2) This can be clearly explained through the fact that there are universals "out there" (=mind independently)
1/

Done. Really annoying that #Gmail does not allow one to keep basic settings unless one also accepts AI. Basically bullying everyone into accepting AI.
Here’s how to opt out.
“Google seems to be opting you in to these features without your permission. Second, the company doesn't seem to have notified its users about this. As a Gmail user, I don't recall seeing any notifications about this change.”
Google's AI is now snooping on your emails - here's how to opt out
A new change quietly rolling out allows Google to access your private messages and attachments to train its AI models - likely without your knowledge. Opting out takes just moments.
www.zdnet.com

I usually fill my empty hours w either reading Sanskrit or doing something teaching-related (prepping, reading assignments…). Today I spent the whole afternoon doing no research at all but only answering emails/organising workshops and the like. But, unsurprisingly, I am far from done:-( #academia

At UofT_Religion, you will be expected to have a developed research project. At UofT_Philosophy, this is not expected, because students will have to take one-two years coursework before settling for a specific topic.
16/

The problem is: Students don't know what they don't know! And AI pollutes the wells, so that they would go to an AI-source to check!

2/2

"Recently, the American Historical Association […] asserts that “banning generative AI is not a long-term solution; cultivating AI literacy is.” One of their suggestions is to assign students an AI-generated essay & have them assess what it got right, got wrong or if it even understood the text"
1/
“We live in an era where personal expression is saturated by digital filters, hivemind thinking is promoted through endless algorithms and academic freedom itself is under assault by the weakest minds among us. #AI has only made this worse. It is a crisis.” #HigherEd www.huffpost.com/entry/histor...
I Set A Trap To Catch My Students Cheating With AI. The Results Were Shocking.
"Students are not just undermining their ability to learn, but to someday lead."
www.huffpost.com

Reposted by Elisa Freschi

“We live in an era where personal expression is saturated by digital filters, hivemind thinking is promoted through endless algorithms and academic freedom itself is under assault by the weakest minds among us. #AI has only made this worse. It is a crisis.” #HigherEd www.huffpost.com/entry/histor...
I Set A Trap To Catch My Students Cheating With AI. The Results Were Shocking.
"Students are not just undermining their ability to learn, but to someday lead."
www.huffpost.com

Sounds interesting! What are the merits of distraction you discussed about?

Institute of Virology

Let's add ChatGPT being allowed to this mess, what could possibly go wrong?